EUR 426,000 more expensive yet the best tender: Heusden-Zolder could award the restoration of the Zolder mine building to the architects’ team that scored 0 out of 35 on price
The temporary association Lens°Ass – Libost offered the lowest price for the design contract to convert the winding-engine building of the former Zolder coal mine into a passive-house school, but lost to AAQ, which was the most expensive and scored 0 out of 35 on fees, because its concept note scored only 17 out of 50 — and the Council of State held that the municipality did not have to deduce a vision from sketches and reference projects that had not been written out in the note.
What happened?
The municipality of Heusden-Zolder wanted to restore and renovate the winding-engine building on the former Zolder mine site into a school built to passive-house standard. On 29 March 2010 the municipal executive approved the specifications for the design contract covering architecture, structural engineering and building services, estimated at EUR 1,718,000 excl. VAT and to be awarded through an open call for tenders. The notice appeared on 2 April 2010 in the Official Journal of the EU and the Belgian Tender Bulletin. The award criteria were a concept note setting out the approach and methodology (50 points), budget control and site supervision (10 points) and fees (40 points: 5 for a note, 35 for the fee itself). The concept note had to contain a written vision on monument restoration, school building and passive construction, and on the project itself. For fees, the lowest amount received 35 points; one point was deducted for each started tranche of EUR 10,000 above the lowest fee, calculated on a works budget of just over EUR 13.8 million for the buildings and just over EUR 0.5 million for external works. Four teams submitted tenders on 31 May 2010 and all four were selected. The evaluation report of 19 July 2010 gave the temporary trading company Lens°Ass Architecten – Libost Groep the lowest price, EUR 1,432,501.73, and 59 points: 17 out of 50 for the concept note, 4 out of 10 for budget control and site supervision and 38 out of 40 for fees. The temporary association AAQ (Architectuur Atelier, Axis Architecten & Ingenieurs and Q-Bus Architectenbureau) was the most expensive at EUR 1,858,674.58 and scored 0 out of 35 on the fee, but 49 out of 50 for the concept note and 10 out of 10 for budget control and site supervision, giving 64 points. On 23 July 2010 the executive awarded the contract to AAQ. On 18 August 2010 Lens°Ass – Libost applied for suspension under the extreme-urgency procedure. It found it manifestly unreasonable that by far the most expensive bidder won, and even believed it had been ranked third. It also alleged unequal treatment: its vision on monument restoration and school building was apparent from two sketch designs, reference projects and an oral presentation; daylight in the classrooms was praised for AAQ but not mentioned for it; the proximity of Q-Bus, five minutes from the site, earned AAQ 5 out of 5 for site supervision, whereas its own building-services subcontractor was also based in Heusden-Zolder; and the combined heat and power unit proposed by AAQ was said to be useless in a passive building. In a second plea it complained that AAQ’s references had merely been marked ‘OK’. The Council of State dismissed the application. The number 3 next to the applicants was simply the sequence number at the opening of tenders; they were in fact second, so the points score was decisive. In a call for tenders the authority chooses the most advantageous tender, not necessarily the cheapest. On the concept note, the Council found that the applicants did not claim to have written out their vision in the note; the municipality could not be expected to distil it, if need be with an expert, from sketches and references. The daylight and the subcontractor in Heusden-Zolder did not appear in the written tender. The applicants did not show that the passive-house standard ruled out any use of combined heat and power, and did not address the core criticism that their ideas were ‘rather rudimentary’, without area calculations or clear choices on external works and building services. The municipality was also entitled to prefer a detailed quantity survey with interim checks over an elemental cost estimate in the preliminary design stage. Finally, the references were a selection requirement, not an award criterion; an ‘OK’ at the selection stage sufficed, and AAQ had listed, among others, the C-mine site in Winterslag as a reference. The applicants bear costs of EUR 350, half each; the intervening parties bear the EUR 375 for their intervention, one third each.
Why does this matter?
The judgment shows sharply that the lowest price in a call for tenders is no guarantee of winning. With a price formula deducting one point per EUR 10,000, a price difference of more than EUR 426,000 was entirely offset by a 32-point gap on the concept note. That is not unlawful as long as the award criteria and their weighting were set out in the specifications beforehand and the assessment is reasoned. The reasoning on the concept note remains especially relevant: the contracting authority assesses what is in the tender, not what a bidder adds afterwards or hopes the panel will deduce from sketches, references or an oral presentation. Anyone alleging unequal treatment because a strong point was mentioned for a competitor must be able to show where that same point appeared in their own written tender. The judgment also confirms the classic distinction between selection and award: references serving as a selection requirement need not be reassessed or extensively reasoned at the award stage.
The lesson
For bidders, and design teams in particular: write out your vision in the note the specifications require, point by point, with the concrete choices and calculations expected. Sketches, reference projects and a presentation can support it but do not replace a written vision, and the contracting authority need not reconstruct it. Explicitly mention every asset you want to count — a local subcontractor, daylight in the classrooms, the split of fees — in the note intended for it. If you are the cheapest, check how heavily price actually weighs in the formula; with 35 out of 100 points and a sliding scale, a strong qualitative bid can more than offset a much higher price. For contracting authorities: this judgment shows what makes a quality assessment defensible — specifications that state exactly what the note must contain, an evaluation report that names weaknesses concretely (‘rudimentary, no area calculation, no choices on building services’) and a clear separation between selection requirements and award criteria.
Ask yourself
Is every vision the specifications ask for written out in your note, or are you counting on the panel to deduce it from sketches and references? Have you explicitly mentioned local presence, subcontractors and other assets you want to score with in the right note? Do you know how many points a EUR 100,000 price difference earns you under the formula in the specifications, and how that compares to the quality criteria? If you allege unequal treatment, can you point to the page of your tender containing the point that was rewarded for the competitor? As a contracting authority: does your evaluation report state concretely why a concept note is weak, and do you keep selection requirements such as references separate from the award criteria?
About this database
The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →