Rejection French-speaking chamber

European Dynamics challenges its exclusion but leaves the award to Cronos untouched: a bidder that no longer wants to perform has no interest left

Ruling nr. 207502 · 22 September 2010 · VIe kamer

The Greek IT provider European Dynamics challenged before the Council of State its exclusion from negotiations on an IT contract worth EUR 3 to 4 million for the Federal Public Service Mobility, but deliberately left the subsequent award to Cronos unchallenged because it no longer wished to perform the contract — so it could no longer show any benefit from an annulment, and its action was dismissed as inadmissible.

What happened?

On 11 May 2007 the Federal Public Service Mobility and Transport launched, by a notice in the Official Journal of the European Union and the Belgian Bulletin of Tenders, a services contract under the negotiated procedure with publication: the computerisation and management of a central system of examination questions, the recognition of examination and refresher-training centres, and the monitoring of training in the context of professional competence. The term was 36 months and the estimate between EUR 3 and 4 million. Eleven requests to participate were received; ten candidates, including European Dynamics, were invited to tender, and on 12 September 2007 nine tenders were submitted. On 1 October 2007 the evaluation committee found four tenders non-compliant, including European Dynamics’; five bidders went on to negotiate. The reason for the exclusion lay in the price. To give all bidders a common basis, the specifications had fixed the number of examination centres at 50, and the cost — worth 40 points — had to be calculated on that basis. In its price schedule, however, European Dynamics assumed a staggered roll-out: 10 centres in the first year, 30 in the second and 10 in the third. According to the administration the price offer therefore contained ‘erroneous elements’ and could not be included in the comparison. Negotiations ran from 8 to 12 October 2007; on 13 November the minister approved the proposal to award to Cronos, and on 14 November the excluded candidates received a registered letter stating the reasons for their exclusion. The Council of State rejected European Dynamics’ extreme-urgency application by judgment no. 177.595 of 4 December 2007; the next day, 5 December 2007, the contract was awarded to Cronos. On 14 January 2008 European Dynamics brought an action for annulment directed solely against the exclusion decision of 1 October 2007. The first auditor considered that the action should also have been directed against the award decision. European Dynamics disputed this in its final brief: the contract ran for 36 months and would be (almost) fully performed by the time of judgment, without a suspension it no longer had any interest in performing the contract itself, the ‘after-sales’ service on a system built by Cronos would be technically difficult and economically unprofitable, and in any event the award decision had never been notified to it. The Council of State did not agree. It had learned of the award through the defence brief, and the lack of notification did not prevent it from challenging that decision. The interest in challenging an exclusion from negotiations lies in retaining a chance of obtaining the contract; once the contract has been awarded, that interest remains current only if the applicant also challenges the award. European Dynamics did not do so, stated itself that it no longer wished to perform the contract, and nowhere indicated what benefit annulling the exclusion alone could still bring. The action was dismissed as inadmissible; European Dynamics bears the costs of EUR 175.

Why does this matter?

The judgment exposes a trap that still catches bidders today: anyone excluded at one stage of a multi-stage procedure who challenges that exclusion must extend the action as soon as the contract is awarded to someone else. Otherwise the interest evaporates. In procurement litigation, the interest in an annulment is concrete: a chance of still obtaining the contract. An applicant who openly says it no longer wants to perform the contract, and therefore lets the award pass, deprives itself of that chance — and with it, of access to the court. The argument that the award decision was never notified does not help once the applicant learns of it through the proceedings. The judgment also shows how decisive the timing of the extreme-urgency ruling can be: suspension was refused on 4 December and the award followed the next day. Whoever fails to obtain suspension faces a choice that must be made deliberately: challenge the award or abandon the case. A middle course — having only one’s own exclusion annulled — achieves nothing.

The lesson

If you are excluded in a negotiated, restricted or other multi-stage procedure and you challenge that exclusion, keep a close eye on the rest of the procedure. As soon as the contract is awarded to someone else, you must also challenge the award decision, within the time limit running from when you learn of it — even if it was never notified to you. Do not state in your briefs that you no longer want or are able to perform the contract unless you are prepared to give up your action. If your main aim is to have an illegality established with a view to damages, make clear from the outset what concrete benefit the annulment brings you, and check which procedure is the right one for that. Separately: calculate your price on the basis the specifications impose — here 50 examination centres — and not on your own, more realistic scenario; you can add that as further information or as a variant if need be. For contracting authorities, the judgment confirms that an applicant who does not challenge the award no longer has an interest in annulling its exclusion; but it is no licence to withhold the award decision from those excluded earlier in the procedure who have brought an action.

Ask yourself

After challenging your exclusion, did you follow the rest of the procedure and challenge the later award decision in time? Can you state concretely what benefit an annulment would bring you, and is what you say in your briefs consistent with that interest? Is your price offer calculated on the basis the specifications impose on all bidders, such as a fixed number of sites, users or centres? Do you know that the absence of notification of the award decision does not relieve you of the need to challenge it once you are aware of it? As a contracting authority: do you notify the award decision also to candidates and bidders who were excluded earlier in the procedure and have brought an action?

About this database

The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →