Dexia is not a public authority: no Council of State for a tender the bank issued as developer of the Middelkerke car park
NV Daniel Seru en Zonen sought suspension of the award of the redevelopment of the Marktplein in Middelkerke to BVBA Tuinen Descamps, but that contract had been awarded by NV Dexia Bank België, which was building the underground car park for the municipality as a private developer under a real-estate lease; the Council of State held that a private-law company unable to take decisions binding on third parties is not an administrative authority, even though it had to follow public procurement law, and dismissed the application for lack of jurisdiction.
What happened?
In September 2007 the municipality of Middelkerke tendered a public services contract for the financing and project management of the construction of an underground car park in the Oostendelaan, including the ‘complete redevelopment of the surface’. The contract went to NV Dexia Bank België. On 1 April 2010 the municipality and Dexia concluded an agreement creating a building right (recht van opstal), approved by the municipal council on 6 May 2010. Both the specifications of the services contract and the building-right agreement expressly provided that the contractors for the works were to be appointed in accordance with public procurement legislation. Dexia then itself tendered a works contract, divided into lots awarded separately. The case concerned the lot for the surface works and square: the ‘Redevelopment of the Oostendelaan N318 including the Marktplein and the Molenstraat – Sub-file Marktplein and Populierenlaan’, through an open tender. The works included breaking up paving and sewers, earthworks, paving in asphalt, concrete pavers, natural stone and clay pavers, sewers, street furniture and play equipment, a new room for chlorine and hydrochloric acid storage at the swimming pool, and landscaping. The specifications named the municipality as ‘initiator’ and user, Dexia as ‘developer’ (bouwheer) and TMVW-AquaRio as ‘co-financier’; the sewer works were borne by TMVW-AquaRio, the surface works by Dexia. The specifications also explained that Dexia was building the project for the municipality under a real-estate lease, under which the municipality would, after completion, be subrogated to Dexia’s rights and obligations as developer; by submitting a bid, the contractor accepted that subrogation. The contract was published on 10 May 2010 in the Bulletin der Aanbestedingen and on 11 May 2010 in the Official Journal of the European Union. At the opening on 29 June 2010 there were four offers, including one from NV Daniel Seru en Zonen. On 7 September 2010 Dexia approved the award report and awarded the contract to BVBA Tuinen Descamps. Seru learned by fax the same day and by registered letter of 9 September that its offer had not been retained as the lowest regular offer, with the reasoned decision and award report attached and a reference to a 15-calendar-day standstill period. On 23 September 2010 Seru asked the Council of State to suspend, under extreme urgency, the rejection and the award, decisions ‘issued by the second respondent (and probably confirmed/to be confirmed by the first respondent)’. Tuinen Descamps intervened. The municipality and Dexia both argued that the Council lacked jurisdiction because the decisions were Dexia’s, and Dexia was not an administrative authority within the meaning of article 14, § 1, of the coordinated laws. The Council relied on two Court of Cassation judgments (14 February 1997 and 10 June 2005): a public limited company entrusted with a task of general interest remains a private-law entity if it cannot take decisions binding on third parties, even if a public authority set it up and it is subject to extensive public control. This gives rise to a presumption that the Council has no jurisdiction over a private legal person, unless it is proven that the entity does have such decision-making power and that the contested decision rests on it. That Dexia was a public limited company was undisputed, and Seru did not provide that proof or even attempt to. On the contrary: in a writ of 21 September 2010 before the president of the Bruges court of first instance sitting in summary proceedings, Seru itself had written that Dexia was not an administrative authority and that the ordinary court in summary proceedings alone had jurisdiction; at the hearing it had that position noted again, on condition that Dexia and the municipality would endorse it in Bruges too. Also in view of the subject matter of the contract, part of the wider construction of the car park complex, the Council found the objection highly serious: Dexia did not appear to have acted as an administrative authority, so its decisions did not appear to be open to annulment and hence not to suspension. The application was dismissed. Seru bears 175 euros in costs, Tuinen Descamps 125 euros for its intervention.
Why does this matter?
The judgment is a reminder that the applicability of public procurement rules and the jurisdiction of the Council of State are two different questions. Under the municipality’s specifications and the building-right agreement, Dexia had to follow public procurement legislation, and it did: open tender, publication in the Bulletin and the Official Journal, award report, standstill period. Yet the rejected bidder could not go to the Council of State, which only rules on acts of administrative authorities, and a bank acting as private developer in a real-estate lease and building-right structure is not one. The test is not who conceived the project or who will ultimately own it, but whether the deciding entity can unilaterally take decisions binding on third parties. For bidders this is crucial in public-private structures — leasing, building rights, project finance, concessions — in which a private party tenders the works: legal protection then runs through the ordinary courts. It is also striking that the applicant had already started summary proceedings in Bruges and shared the respondents’ position there; the extreme-urgency application to the Council was essentially a safety net here, and the Council disposed of it quickly.
The lesson
For bidders: check for each tender who legally awards the contract, not just for whom the works are intended. If a private developer, leasing company or project vehicle appears on the specifications, the Council of State in principle has no jurisdiction and you must go to the president of the court in summary proceedings. If you opt for two procedures to be safe, be consistent in your positions: arguing before the ordinary court that the respondent is not an administrative authority makes it easy for the Council of State to decline jurisdiction. For authorities and their private partners: make clear in the specifications who the developer is and who takes the award decision, and state in the notification to bidders before which court suspension can be sought. A structure in which the municipality in fact takes or confirms the decisions itself may change the picture — the applicant suggested as much, but offered no proof.
Ask yourself
As a bidder: do you know who legally takes the award decision in this contract — a public authority or a private developer, leasing company or project vehicle? If the decision comes from a private legal person, have you brought summary proceedings before the president of the court of first instance in time? Are the positions you take in parallel proceedings on the nature of the respondent consistent with each other? As an authority or private developer: do the specifications and the notification clearly state who takes the award decision and which court has jurisdiction? Does the municipality in your structure itself take or confirm the award decision, and are you aware of the consequences for which court has jurisdiction?
About this database
The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →