An insurance certificate is not VCA: Martens André is left out of the selection for Belham’s polder maintenance, and the award itself cannot even be challenged yet
The Polder of Belham did not select Grond- en Kraanwerken Martens André for a restricted tender for watercourse maintenance works because it held no ISO certificate or VCA safety certificate; the Council of State held that the reference ‘(ISO certification, VCA certificate, etc.)’ in the contract notice only allowed truly similar certificates — not an insurer’s statement on workplace accidents or certificates of satisfactory performance — and declared the action against the award, not yet approved by the provincial governor, inadmissible.
What happened?
On 3 September 2010 the Polder of Belham published, in the Belgian Bulletin of Tenders, a restricted tender for routine maintenance works on the watercourses within its district: mowing, clearing and bank-reinforcement works from 1 November 2010 to 30 September 2015, estimated at 1,474,717.75 euros including VAT. As objective criteria to choose the limited number of candidates (minimum five, maximum six), the notice listed among other things ‘documents demonstrating that the quality and safety of performance are guaranteed (ISO certification, VCA certificate, etc.)’, alongside registration, accreditation in category B class 4, references for similar works and a social-security certificate. Six candidates applied in time. Grond- en Kraanwerken Martens André from Jabbeke held no ISO or VCA certificate, but enclosed a statement from its insurer that no workplace accidents had been reported since 2006, and a series of certificates of satisfactory performance. On 21 September 2010 the polder selected only three candidates — A. Audenaert from Laarne, Carpentier from Lokeren and Cocquyt from Beervelde — and excluded Martens ‘because it holds neither an ISO certificate nor a VCA certificate relating to work on watercourses’. The letter informing it was dated 21 September but only sent on 29 September 2010. On 7 October 2010 the three selected candidates’ tenders were opened; the same day, Martens’s lawyer requested the selection decision. On 11 October 2010 the polder awarded the contract to Audenaert for 1,532,519.45 euros including VAT, and a day later replied that the award was awaiting approval by the supervisory authority and that the requested documents would follow once that approval had been given. On 14 October 2010 Martens sought suspension under extreme urgency of both the non-selection and the award. The Council split the case. Article 85 of the Polders Act makes the award decision subject to the approval of the provincial governor; as long as that approval is lacking, an action against the award is inadmissible. That supervision does not apply to the non-selection: that decision deprived Martens of any chance of the contract, had already been implemented and — as the General Assembly had already held in Amec Spie Belgium (no. 152.174 of 2 December 2005) — could be challenged separately. Because the contract was published after 24 February 2010, a serious plea sufficed, even below the EU threshold. The first plea, that the polder had read the notice more strictly after the fact than it was worded, did not convince. The express mention of ISO and VCA should have alerted Martens that a high, certified level of quality and safety was required, and ‘etc.’ only covered truly similar certificates. An insurer’s statement and certificates of satisfactory performance are, prima facie, not such certificates. The polder applied the notice ‘perhaps strictly, but not carelessly’; Martens moreover appeared to be the only candidate without either certificate, so no further formal reasoning was needed. The second plea — that the polder had not communicated the non-selection decision before inviting tenders, in breach of article 65/7 of the Act of 24 December 1993 — concerned the course of the procedure after selection and could not affect the selection decision itself. The application was dismissed; Martens bore the costs of 175 euros.
Why does this matter?
The judgment contains two lessons, each worth reading on its own. The first is procedural. Where an authority’s award decision is subject to supervisory approval — here a polder, whose awards the provincial governor must approve — the award can only be challenged once approved. The selection decision in a restricted procedure, by contrast, stands on its own: it definitively excludes the candidate and can be challenged immediately. Whoever waits for the award therefore risks being too late for the non-selection; whoever immediately challenges the award runs into admissibility. The second lesson is substantive. A list in brackets ending with ‘etc.’ opens the door to equivalent evidence, but not to any document that says something about quality or safety. The Council read ‘etc.’ in the light of the certificates expressly named: what is required is a comparable, externally certified quality or safety system. An insurer’s statement or a stack of references does not replace that. Also noteworthy is the finding that a breach of the information duty after selection (the non-selected candidate must receive the reasons before the others are invited) does not make the selection decision itself unlawful. That breach may have consequences for the later stages, but it must then be raised there.
The lesson
For candidates: take a reference such as ‘(ISO certification, VCA certificate, etc.)’ literally. If you lack those certificates, submit a truly equivalent, externally certified system and explain why it is equivalent — an insurance statement or references will not do. If in doubt about its scope, ask the authority before submitting. If you are not selected, challenge that decision immediately: it is separate from the award. Also be aware that an award by an authority under supervisory approval (polders, water boards and the like) only becomes challengeable after approval, so track that approval. For contracting authorities: be as precise as possible in the selection criteria — write ‘ISO 9001, VCA or an equivalent certified system’ rather than an open list in brackets. Communicate the reasons for non-selection before inviting the selected candidates to tender, as the law requires, and do not reply that the documents will only follow after approval of the award.
Ask yourself
Do you hold the quality and safety certificates named in the notice, or a system you can demonstrably present as equivalent? Do you understand that ‘etc.’ in a selection criterion refers to truly similar certificates, and not to any document that says something about quality or safety? Do you know that a non-selection decision in a restricted procedure can be challenged separately and immediately? Is the award decision you want to challenge subject to supervisory approval, and has that approval already been given? As an authority, do you communicate the reasons for non-selection before sending the invitation to tender?
About this database
The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →