A cheaper bid, but no valid decision to litigate: Kepenne-Meplac loses against the Charleroi social welfare centre on its articles of association — the consortium’s manager could not decide alone, and Menuiserie Kepenne had not been a private limited company since 1993
The temporary consortium Kepenne-Meplac, which had offered the lowest price — 80,093 euros — for the fixed furniture of the Couillet care home but was set aside as abnormally low, challenged the award to Brion et Charlot, but the Council of State dismissed the application without looking at the merits: the decision to litigate had been taken by a single manager although the consortium agreement required unanimity, Meplac’s managing director could not represent the public limited company in court on his own, and the decision for Menuiserie Kepenne came from the ‘manager’ of a private limited company that had become a public limited company in 1993.
What happened?
On 17 December 2009 the council of the Charleroi public social welfare centre (CPAS) approved the plans and specifications for lot 9 ‘fixed furniture’ of the first phase of the extension of the Couillet care home. The amount was set at 175,000 euros and the CPAS chose a public tender with European publication; the notice was sent to the Official Journal on 28 December 2009. At the opening on 22 February 2010 there were five bids (excl. VAT): Brion et Charlot from Montignies-sur-Sambre 86,928.50 euros, the temporary consortium Kepenne-Meplac from Ans 80,093.00 euros, MAM Menuiserie from Neupré 100,194.00 euros, Dherte from Flobecq 144,173.30 euros and Menuiserie Freson from Hognoul 113,140.00 euros. The CPAS technical department left out the highest and the lowest bid to calculate an average, arrived at 100,461.87 euros, deducted 15 per cent and so obtained a floor of 85,392.59 euros. According to the department, Kepenne-Meplac was 19 per cent below the average and was regarded as abnormally low. On 22 April 2010 the CPAS council unanimously awarded the lot to Brion et Charlot, as ‘the lowest regular bid’, for the corrected amount of 88,051.61 euros excl. VAT (98,617.80 euros incl. VAT), plus 10,000 euros for price revision and unforeseen works. On 25 May 2010 the temporary consortium Kepenne-Meplac and its two members, Meplac SA and Menuiserie Kepenne, sought suspension and annulment of that award in a single application. The CPAS argued that, despite a request of 31 May 2010, it had never received the exhibits from number 3 onwards, and that only the consortium, not its members individually, had submitted a bid. Presiding judge Odile Daurmont of the VIth chamber, following a report by senior auditor Derouaux in the abridged procedure, went further than the CPAS had asked and examined the decisions to litigate of all applicants. Because the bid came from a temporary consortium, the application had to be lodged by that consortium: it alone had a direct interest. Lacking separate legal personality and any clause on representation in court, however, a temporary consortium can, like any unincorporated association, only litigate if all its members act jointly and regularly, which requires that within each company the legally or statutorily competent body takes the decision. The decision to go to the Council of State had been taken by Philippe Quertainmont, as manager of the consortium under article 6 of the agreement of 8 February 2010, both for the consortium and for Meplac SA. Article 6 gave him management and representation, but article 4 provided that ‘all decisions concerning […] any appeals […] shall be taken unanimously’. An action before the Council of State moreover falls outside day-to-day management; Quertainmont could therefore not take that decision alone. The decision also fell short for Meplac SA. Under article 522(2) of the Companies Code, the board of directors represents a public limited company in court, unless the articles provide otherwise. Article 15 of the articles (coordinated on 30 October 2001) allowed the managing director alone, or two directors jointly, to represent the company ‘towards third parties’, but said nothing about representation in court, and the delegation of day-to-day management in article 14 did not help, since proceedings before the Council of State fall outside it. The extract published in the annexes to the Belgian Official Gazette of 13 October 2000 left no doubt: the board should have decided. For Menuiserie Kepenne it was even simpler. The application enclosed the articles of a private limited company published on 23 April 1976, with extracts of 11 January 1984 and 7 September 1990. The Justice Ministry’s database of legal persons showed, however, that the company had become a public limited company on 23 June 1993. The decision to litigate had been taken by Olivier Kepenne ‘as manager of the private limited company’; his appointment was not in the file, and even if it existed, it gave him no power to represent a public limited company in court. The application was dismissed, there was no further need to rule on suspension, and the applicants bore the costs of 525 euros, 175 euros each. Whether Kepenne-Meplac’s price had rightly been found abnormally low was not addressed.
Why does this matter?
The judgment shows how a case that looked substantively interesting — the lowest bid set aside through an arithmetical threshold of average minus 15 per cent — was lost before the Council even looked at it. The lesson concerns consortia. A temporary consortium has no legal personality. If its agreement contains no clause on representation in court, it can only litigate when all its members, each through its own competent body, take the decision. A consortium manager who under the agreement must have appeals decided unanimously cannot do so alone. And within a public limited company, day-to-day management is not enough: proceedings before the Council of State fall outside it, and unless the articles expressly entrust representation in court to one or more directors, the board must decide. A clause on representation ‘towards third parties’ does not suffice. Notably, the Council itself consulted the database of legal persons and thereby found that the articles enclosed with the application had been out of date since 1993. The CPAS had only contested admissibility for the two members; the Council examined the decisions of all applicants, the consortium included. For contracting authorities, the judgment is a reminder that such admissibility questions are worth examining, but that they do not settle a substantive dispute over the method for detecting abnormally low prices.
The lesson
For tenderers bidding as a consortium: state expressly in the consortium agreement who represents the consortium in court and how quickly a decision to litigate can be taken — time limits in procurement litigation are short. If the agreement requires unanimity for appeals, secure a written decision from all members. Have the right body decide within each company: for a public limited company, as a rule the board of directors, unless the articles expressly give representation in court to one or more directors. Enclose the current articles, the appointment of the bodies and the decision itself with the application, and check that the legal form is still correct. Also send the exhibits to the other side. For contracting authorities: when faced with an action, check exactly who is litigating and whether the decision to litigate was regularly taken, especially for consortia. At the same time, realise that an admissibility defence does not answer whether your method for spotting abnormally low prices holds up; an arithmetical threshold is at most a signal that a price investigation is needed.
Ask yourself
Does your consortium agreement contain a clause on representation in court, and how is a decision to litigate taken? Has the competent body within each participating company decided to go to the Council of State? Do the articles of your public limited company expressly empower one or more directors to represent the company in court, or must the board decide? Are the articles you enclose with the application the current ones, with the correct legal form and the deed appointing the bodies? As an authority, do you check the admissibility of an action, without forgetting that the substance of your decision must be equally sound?
About this database
The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →