Annulment French-speaking chamber

Oupeye measures SITA’s regular tender against an irregular one, calls its price ‘unacceptable’ and then invokes extreme urgency for household waste collection: the Council of State annuls the decision not to award, the negotiated procedure and the award to O.V.S.

Ruling nr. 209316 · 30 November 2010 · VIe kamer

After the lowest tender in Oupeye and Visé’s joint procurement for household waste collection proved irregular, Oupeye abandoned the award on the ground that the remaining prices were ‘unacceptable’ compared with that irregular tender, and awarded the contract to O.V.S. through a negotiated procedure without publication on grounds of extreme urgency; the Council of State held that a regular tender may not be measured against an irregular one and that failed procedures and a fixed start date are not unforeseeable events, and annulled all three decisions.

What happened?

The municipalities of Oupeye and Visé organised a joint services contract for household waste collection and transport, awarded by public tender to the lowest regular offer, to start on 1 January 2007 when the existing contract with SITA expired. The notice was published only on 22 June 2006 and the opening was postponed to 4 September 2006, when four tenders were received: the temporary association SHANKS-O.V.S. at EUR 477,018.42, SITA at EUR 539,735.78, C.T.L. at EUR 585,040.25 and BIFFA at EUR 693,475.20. Oupeye requested a price justification from the lowest tenderer on 5 September; SITA flagged the abnormally low price the same day. The association’s members gave conflicting answers: SHANKS, without consulting its partner, reported an erroneous unit price that would push the association to second place, while O.V.S. justified the prices in detail, citing its proximity. On 2 October 2006 the Oupeye college abandoned the tender under Article 18 of the Law of 24 December 1993, finding the regular tenders’ prices ‘unacceptable’ compared with the price O.V.S. had justified, and decided — with Visé’s agreement — to use a negotiated procedure without publication on grounds of extreme urgency resulting from unforeseeable events, consulting six firms with a fifteen-day deadline. On 18 October O.V.S. (EUR 462,624.75), SITA (EUR 518,492.26) and C.T.L. (EUR 530,000) tendered, and on 30 October 2006, after withdrawing an earlier award of 23 October, the college awarded the contract to SPRL O.V.S. at EUR 462,624.75 a year. SITA sought annulment on 27 October 2006; its suspension request was rejected by judgment no. 166.714 of 16 January 2007, but it continued the proceedings. The Council rejected Oupeye’s objections on jurisdiction and on SITA’s allegedly illegitimate interest: if the SHANKS-O.V.S. tender was irregular, SITA’s was the lowest regular tender and should have won, and choosing an ordinary rather than an urgent suspension request did not make its interest illegitimate, particularly as the municipality awarded the contract without awaiting the ruling. On the merits, Oupeye was not required to attach the O.V.S. letter, since the decision rested on the price gap SITA already knew. But prices can only be compared between comparable — that is, regular — tenders; having treated the SHANKS-O.V.S. tender as irregular because its real price was uncertain, Oupeye could not deem SITA’s regular price unacceptable by reference to it. Of its own motion, the Council also held that the risk of irregular tenders or unacceptable prices, and the practical preparations for starting the contract, are not unforeseeable events: Oupeye had known since the previous contract was concluded that the new one had to start on 1 January 2007 and should have planned accordingly, and could certainly not rely on delays caused by its own unlawful decision. The Council thus departed from the President of the Liège Court of First Instance, who had accepted urgency in interim proceedings. All three decisions were annulled, with costs of EUR 350 against the municipality.

Why does this matter?

Two lessons still apply. An authority may abandon an award, but ‘unacceptable prices’ must be measured against a valid benchmark — its estimate or market data — not against a tender it considers irregular, which would give the irregular tenderer a second chance at the expense of the lowest regular one. And the extreme-urgency exception is strict: a procedure that fails because of irregular tenders or high prices, or a contract expiring on a long-known date, is not an unforeseeable event. The annulment came four years later, when the contract had long been performed; the judgment says nothing about what happened next, which shows why speed matters for a tenderer that wants the contract itself.

The lesson

Contracting authorities: launch recurring contracts well before the current one expires, with room for delays and a possible re-run; justify any finding of unacceptable prices with your estimate or objective market data; and never treat a failed procedure as an unforeseeable event. Tenderers: flag suspected abnormally low prices in time, challenge an abandonment if you are the lowest regular tenderer, and use the fast-track procedure if you want the contract itself. Members of a temporary association: agree who answers the authority, as conflicting answers can render the tender irregular.

Ask yourself

As an authority: is there enough time between launching the procedure and the expiry of the current contract to re-run it if needed? What benchmark do you use for ‘unacceptable’ prices? Is your reliance on urgency based on truly unforeseeable events? As a tenderer: are you the lowest regular tenderer after the abandonment, and are you using a procedure fast enough to win the contract? As an association member: who answers the authority on your behalf?

About this database

The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →