An electric winch that must cool down after 4.32 metres: for two years Fire Technics could not prove its forest-fire tanker met the specifications
The FPS Home Affairs rejected Fire Technics’ tender for forest-fire tankers because, despite eighteen months of requests, it never showed that its electric winch met the essential requirement of at least 50 kN of pulling force over the full usable cable length without overheating; the Council of State found none of the pleas serious, held that Fire Technics, as an irregular tenderer, had no interest in its claim, and dismissed the application for suspension in extreme urgency.
What happened?
The FPS Home Affairs launched a general call for tenders (algemene offerteaanvraag) for the supply of all-terrain forest-fire tankers for the Belgian emergency services, published on 24 July 2008 in the Bulletin der Aanbestedingen and the Official Journal of the EU. Special specifications II/MAT/A21-214-07 drew a sharp line between essential requirements — failure meant exclusion — and advantage criteria that earned extra points. For essential requirements, tenderers had to enclose ‘detailed and documented technical information’. Point 1.14.4 required the winch to deliver ‘≥ 50 kN on each cable layer’, ‘available over the usable cable length without overheating of the drive’, with a usable length of at least 20 metres. Only two tenders were submitted on 7 October 2008: from NV Etn. Pol Vanassche & Cie and from NV Fire Technics. Vanassche offered a hydraulic winch and had enclosed a statement from Warn Industries, the winch manufacturer, that an electric winch cannot reach the required pull over a longer distance because it shuts down from overheating. Fire Technics offered such an electric Warn winch. Asked on 17 December 2008 whether its winch could work continuously at full load, Fire Technics replied on 12 January 2009 that it pulled at least 5,000 kg (5,376 kg) at 24.1 metres and that the vehicle battery could supply the power. Wiegel, the Belgian importer of Warn winches, told the authority on 2 February 2009 that under about 5.4 tonnes the motor cuts out after 2.4 minutes and must cool for ten minutes — by then only 4.32 metres of cable has been wound in. Eighteen months of correspondence followed: a request for confirmation from the manufacturer (‘not the importer!’), a proposed performance test for which Fire Technics quoted almost EUR 23,900 excl. VAT (deemed too high), repeated requests for a full file of evidence, an undated Wiegel letter calling the winch ‘compliant’ while recommending a hydraulic one, an offer at no extra cost of an electro-hydraulic winch, a Wiegel e-mail of 15 January 2010 confirming the 4.32 metres, and finally questions of 9 March 2010 that Fire Technics never answered, citing an office move. On 18 October 2010 the Minister awarded the contract to Vanassche at EUR 250,654.00 excl. VAT per vehicle and declared Fire Technics’ tender irregular because its compliance with point 1.14.4 was not established. Fire Technics sought suspension in extreme urgency on 9 November 2010; NV Vanassche Firefighting Engineering intervened. Presiding judge Dierk Verbiest first held that the new remedies law of 23 December 2009 did not apply because the contract had been published well before 25 February 2010, so serious harm that is difficult to repair still had to be shown. He then rejected all six pleas: the tender was excluded not because the winch was electric but because conformity was not proven; consulting Wiegel directly was lawful since the findings were put to Fire Technics; asking for manufacturer confirmation was not excessive and refusing to pay for the test was not careless; disclosure of the tender to the competitor was not proven; Article 11 of the Law of 24 December 1993 targets collusion between tenderers, not the authority’s conduct; the second plea was inadmissible as obscurum libellum. As an irregular tenderer that showed neither its own regularity, nor the irregularity of the winner’s tender, nor a fatal flaw in the whole procedure, Fire Technics had no interest. The intervention was granted, the claim dismissed, and the intervener bore the intervention costs of EUR 125.
Why does this matter?
The judgment places the burden of proof for essential technical requirements where it belongs: on the tenderer. Repeating that a product is ‘compliant’ is not enough when the specifications demand documented technical information, nor is an ambiguous importer’s letter that says ‘compliant’ while recommending a different winch. It also shows how an authority may act when in doubt: it may seek information from a supplier or importer itself, provided it puts the findings to the tenderer and lets it respond — even if the doubt was triggered by material the competitor attached to its own tender. Finally, it recalls the procedural threshold: an irregular tenderer challenging an award to someone else must first restore its own regularity or show that no one could lawfully win; otherwise the Council goes no further.
The lesson
Tenderers: read essential technical requirements literally and enclose the proof. ‘Pulling force available over the usable cable length without overheating’ is a performance requirement, not a choice of type. If the authority asks for manufacturer confirmation, deliver exactly that document — not a restatement of your position or a vague letter from an intermediary. A free substitute offered afterwards does not cure an irregular tender. Contracting authorities: ask all tenderers the same questions, put information you obtain from third parties to the tenderer concerned, set deadlines, and reason the irregularity step by step in the award decision — and specify in the tender documents which evidence you expect, to avoid a two-year saga.
Ask yourself
Have you enclosed, for every essential requirement, the evidence asked for, and does it prove the performance as worded in the specifications? Does your technical confirmation come from the manufacturer or only from an importer or distributor? Do you know what the manufacturer publishes about your product’s limits, and could a competitor use it? Do you answer requests for clarification with new, verifiable data? And as an authority: do you put third-party information to the tenderer for comment, and do your specifications state exactly what proof you expect?
About this database
The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →