Rejection Dutch-speaking chamber

DSV left the 90,000 euros of item 86 out of its total and justified only unit prices on the Vlaamsesteenweg: whoever ignores the question about the ‘overall tender price’ remains a non-compliant bidder

Ruling nr. 210375 · 13 January 2011 · XIIe kamer

The Council of State dismisses DSV NV’s action against the award of the redevelopment of the Vlaamsesteenweg in Brussels to Verhaeren & Co: the federal authority had expressly asked DSV to justify ‘the level of [its] overall tender price’ as well, DSV merely pointed to a forgotten item of 90,000 euros and put forward no objective element at all, so its tender was rightly rejected as abnormally low and irregular — without the authority having to say whether it was applying § 3 or § 4 of Article 110 or to disclose its calculation of the average.

What happened?

The Federal Public Service Mobility and Transport put out a public tender for the redevelopment of the Vlaamsesteenweg in the Brussels-Capital Region (special specifications TIW/VII.0.3), published in the Bulletin der Aanbestedingen of 25 October 2002. At the opening on 25 November 2002 there were twelve tenders. DSV NV was the cheapest at 1,018,031.82 euros (VAT included); Verhaeren & Co NV followed at 1,187,921.87 euros. The most expensive tenders came from Socogetra (1,549,729.28 euros) and Van Hoorebeeck (1,546,727.88 euros). On 28 November 2002 the authority asked DSV by fax and registered letter, ‘pursuant to Art. 110 of the Royal Decree of 08.01.1996’, to provide a justification both for its unit prices for seven items (including breaking up road surfaces, pavements and kerbs, excavations and a lean-concrete foundation) and ‘for the level of [its] overall tender price’. DSV replied on 9 December 2002 with a detailed calculation of the unit prices. As to the total price, it merely stated that the sum of 90,000 euros for item 86 had not been carried into the final total, so that its tender actually amounted to 931,348.61 euros excluding and 1,126,931.82 euros including VAT. The authority accepted none of the justifications: according to its memo, DSV had not justified its overall price and the unit prices did not cover the normal work. On 8 April 2003 the minister declared DSV’s tender irregular, because it deviated by more than 15% from the average calculated under Article 110, § 4, and because DSV put forward ‘no objective element whatsoever’ capable of explaining the price difference. The contract went to Verhaeren & Co for 1,187,946.88 euros. DSV only learned on 15 October 2003 that its tender had not been retained and received the award decision on 26 November 2003. On 23 January 2004 it brought an action for annulment. DSV argued that it did not know the authority was applying § 4 (the 15% threshold) rather than § 3, and that it would otherwise have shown that its corrected tender was only 14.98% below the correctly calculated average of 1,325,558.33 euros. Moreover, nothing showed how the authority had calculated the average; the calculation tables in the administrative file bore the date 16 February 2004, i.e. after the action was brought. The Council rejected these arguments. Article 110 does not require the contracting authority to state which paragraph it is applying, and the letter expressly requested a justification of the overall price. DSV itself admitted that it had not defended itself against the claim that its tender was 15% below the average, and it had put forward no objective explanatory factor. Nor must the authority disclose its calculation of the average or the percentage of deviation. The tables showed that the calculation had been made, DSV did not contest that calculation, and the Council accepted the explanation that 16 February 2004 was simply the print date automatically added by the software. The late notification of the irregularity — six months after the decision — did not make the award unlawful either: a defect in notification does not in principle affect the decision. Since DSV remained a non-compliant bidder because of its abnormal total price, it no longer had an interest in its plea concerning the unit prices. The action was dismissed; DSV bears the costs of 175 euros. An ‘explanatory memorandum’ that the State filed after the reply brief was excluded from the proceedings because the procedural rules do not provide for such a document.

Why does this matter?

The judgment applies the old Royal Decree of 8 January 1996, but its core is timeless: a request for price justification is not a formality, and a bidder who answers only part of the question loses the contract. DSV regarded its total price as a mere arithmetical sum of the items and thought that flagging a forgotten item said it all. The Council took a different view: the authority asked for a justification of ‘the level’ of the overall price, which called for a substantive explanation linked to objective factors such as an economical construction method, a chosen technique or exceptionally favourable conditions. It is also notable that DSV’s own calculation (14.98% below the average, just under the 15% threshold) carried no weight, because it built that defence only before the Council of State and not in its answer to the authority. In addition, the judgment deliberately sets a low bar for contracting authorities on two points: they need not say which legal basis they rely on, and they need not disclose their calculation of the average, as long as that calculation is in the file. Finally, a useful procedural lesson: a bidder whose tender is declared irregular on several grounds must successfully rebut all of them. If the plea against one independent ground fails, the interest in the others falls away.

The lesson

For bidders: answer a request for price justification fully and literally. If the authority asks about your unit prices and your total price, justify both with concrete, objective elements — your working method, your equipment, a favourable location or a special technique. Flagging a calculation error is not a justification. If your tender is close to the threshold relative to the average, make that calculation straight away in your answer and not only in appeal proceedings. Do not wait for an explanation of which legal provision the authority is applying either: any request for price justification can lead to the rejection of your tender. For contracting authorities: phrase the request for justification so that it also covers the total price where that deviates, keep the calculation tables for the average in the file, and state in the award decision why the justification is insufficient. Do inform rejected bidders in good time: a notification six months after the decision did not make the award unlawful here, but it is not good practice.

Ask yourself

As a bidder, have you answered every part of the request for price justification, including the question about the level of your total price? Is your justification based on objective factors (method, technique, favourable conditions) rather than on an arithmetical correction or generalities? For a tender near the 15% threshold, have you already included your own calculation of the average in your answer to the authority? Do you know that the authority need not state the legal basis on which it requests the justification, nor disclose its calculation of the average? As a contracting authority, have you included the calculation tables and the analysis of the price justification in the file in a way that can support the award decision?

About this database

The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →