Annulment Dutch-speaking chamber

158,585 euros as a lump sum for a construction pit where the specifications asked for unit prices per metre: Gabecon’s variant for the Koksijde pumping station was technically sound, but legally irregular

Ruling nr. 210377 · 13 January 2011 · XIIe kamer

The Council of State annuls the award of the shell construction of the ’t Schipgat pumping station in Koksijde to Gabecon, because its variant for shoring the construction pit used a single lump-sum price of 158,585 euros for two items that the specifications required to be priced by schedule of rates on fixed estimated quantities — a free variant could change only the technique, not the pricing method — and because the intermunicipal company could not cast doubt on the regularity of Furnibo’s tender after the event, before the Council.

What happened?

The Intercommunale Waterleidingsmaatschappij van Veurne-Ambacht, an intermunicipal water company, put out a public tender for the shell construction and finishing (lot 1) of a pumping station and clean-water reservoirs at ’t Schipgat in Koksijde, announced in the Bulletin der Aanbestedingen of 11 May 2007. To keep the construction pit open, the specifications provided for an anchored secant pile wall, with the express possibility ‘to submit a variant for this with e.g. a Berlin wall, sheet piling, etc.’. The bill of quantities required, for item 1.16.3, a unit price for 7,500 metres of bored, reinforced and concreted secant piles and, for item 1.16.4, a unit price for cutting off 380 piles. Article 2.8 of the specifications excluded any correction of the estimated quantities. At the opening on 22 June 2007 there were six tenders. Bouwbedrijf Furnibo BVBA submitted no variant. Gabecon did attach a ‘variant note’: temporary shoring of the entire pit, for instance with a Berlin wall or sheet piling, for a total price of 158,585 euros for both items together. That reduced its tender by 350,600 euros to 2,313,352.89 euros excluding VAT. On 28 June 2007 Furnibo faxed the company that it had not submitted a variant because it had assumed the price comparison would use the quantity of secant piles actually to be executed, in its view 3,745 linear metres. Using its own unit prices it then arrived at 2,785,707.45 euros including VAT, lower than Gabecon with its variant, and with sheet piling even at 2,684,167.73 euros. The tender report by architect Piet Steyaert and an engineering firm reached the same conclusion in every version: Gabecon’s variant was the lowest regular tender, Furnibo came second. On 9 July 2007 the board awarded the contract to Gabecon for 2,317,961.25 euros. Furnibo sought annulment on 11 September 2007; the architect intervened. The company and the architect first argued that Furnibo lacked interest, because its tender provided for stairs with hot-dip galvanised treads whereas the specifications required stainless steel. The Council rejected that objection. The company had not expressly assessed the regularity of any tender, admitted that the architect and engineering firm had advised it ‘to pass over this irregularity’, and had ranked Furnibo second. A substantially irregular tender cannot be ranked; claiming the opposite before the Council amounts to an after-the-fact assessment. On the merits, the Council found that items 1.16.3 and 1.16.4 were works by schedule of rates, with unit prices per estimated quantity. The specifications allowed a variant for the shoring technique, but not for the pricing method. A unit price per metre of wall was perfectly possible for a Berlin wall or sheet piling too. Gabecon’s lump-sum price therefore made its variant substantially irregular; it could not be included in the ranking, and the contract did not go to the lowest regular tender, in breach of Article 15 of the Act of 24 December 1993. The architect’s finding that the variant was ‘technically’ compliant made no difference: this was a legal, not a technical, question. For the same reason the Council refused to appoint an expert. The award was annulled. The company bears the costs of the action (175 euros), the architect the costs of his intervention (125 euros).

Why does this matter?

Variants are a classic source of disputes, and this judgment draws a clear line: a free variant opens the door to a different execution technique, not to a different way of pricing. If the specifications require unit prices per estimated quantity and exclude any correction of those quantities, a bidder cannot get round that lock by casting its variant as a single lump sum based on the actual dimensions of the pit. According to Furnibo, Gabecon’s variant was based on the actual size of the pit (3,745 linear metres) rather than on the 7,500 metres in the bill of quantities; the Council did not even need to verify that, as the lump-sum price in itself sufficed. The difference was 350,600 euros. A second lesson concerns the role of designers and engineering firms. Their view that a variant is ‘technically compliant’ does not answer whether it is also regular as regards pricing; that legal test remains the contracting authority’s responsibility. Third, the judgment closes the door on a commonly used defence: an authority that has ranked a tender cannot suddenly argue before the Council of State that it was substantially irregular in order to deny the applicant its interest. What is not in the decision cannot be added afterwards.

The lesson

For bidders: read a free-variant clause carefully. If you may propose a different technique, you remain bound by the price structure of the specifications — unit prices stay unit prices, even when the technique changes. If you have doubts about the estimated quantities in the bill, ask a question before submission; a lump sum based on your own measurement is no solution where the specifications exclude corrections. And if you lose to a competitor who did just that: that is a strong plea. For contracting authorities: describe in the specifications not only what a variant may change, but also how it must be priced. Supplement any technical advice on variants with your own legal review of regularity. Decide expressly on the regularity of all tenders in the award decision: an authority that knowingly overlooks a defect in a competing tender cannot invoke it later to have an action declared inadmissible.

Ask yourself

As a bidder, does your variant respect the price structure of the specifications (unit prices per item and per estimated quantity), or does it also change the pricing method? Is your variant based on quantities that deviate from the bill of quantities, while the specifications exclude correction of estimated quantities? Did you raise any ambiguity about the quantities in the bill before submission, rather than explaining it afterwards in a fax? As a contracting authority, do your specifications set out not only the subject and scope of a free variant, but also how it must be priced? As a contracting authority, have you expressly decided on the regularity of all tenders in the award decision, so that you need not put forward a different assessment afterwards?

About this database

The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →