Suspension Dutch-speaking chamber

Archaeologists do not just dig holes: Bruges excludes a restoration studio from the excavation in the Church of Our Lady for lacking a building contractor’s accreditation, but the Council of State sees mainly services and suspends the award

Ruling nr. 211108 · 8 February 2011 · XIIe kamer

For the archaeological excavations in the Church of Our Lady, needed for thirteen underground heating units, the city of Bruges required accreditation as a general building contractor (category D, class 1) and therefore excluded the bid of Restauratieatelier Ruben Willaert, but the Council of State finds that the contract, focused on archaeological research with recording, processing of finds, reporting and public outreach, is prima facie a services contract to which no accreditation applies, and suspends the award to Monument Vandekerckhove.

What happened?

The city of Bruges was restoring the interior of the Church of Our Lady. This included a new heating system with thirteen underground heating units and trenches for heating ducts and cabling, in a floor above centuries-old graves: a trial excavation in the high choir in 1979 had uncovered seventeen brick graves, including the burial vault of Mary of Burgundy. For lot 1E of phase 5A, ‘archaeological excavations’, the city launched a general call for tenders on the basis of special specifications B.09002. The contract was announced on 10 September 2010 in the Bulletin of Tenders and on 21 September 2010 in the Official Journal of the European Union, each time as a public works contract, requiring accreditation in category D (‘General building contracts’), class 1. The estimate was 121,863.83 euros excluding VAT, later updated to 128,002.11 euros. Item 10.02, ‘excavation of pits and trenches’, accounted for 84,363.83 euros, just over two thirds. The award criteria were the concept note (50 points), price (50) and the work schedule (30). According to the designer’s description attached to the specifications, the excavation aimed, ‘besides recording the information under threat, above all at finding the least disruptive locations for placing the units’, in combination with an earlier ground-penetrating radar survey. The contractor had to deploy an archaeologist experienced in church archaeology, a physical anthropologist and two workers, and was also responsible for recording, collecting finds, sampling, C14 dating, consolidation, public outreach with guided tours, data processing, reporting and deposit with the inter-municipal archaeological service Raakvlak. At the opening on 18 November 2010 there were two bids: Restauratieatelier Ruben Willaert BVBA offered 187,965 euros excluding VAT, Monument Vandekerckhove NV 185,012.58 euros. Willaert was accredited in subcategories D21 (class 1), D23 (class 3) and D24 ‘restoration of monuments’ (class 1), but not in category D itself. In his report of 15 December 2010 the designer therefore considered its bid non-compliant. Monument Vandekerckhove, accredited in category D class 8, had to justify its abnormally high unit prices for processing results and the basic report, which was accepted. On 23 December 2010 the board of mayor and aldermen awarded the contract to it for 223,865.57 euros including VAT, without awarding points since it was the only compliant tenderer. Willaert applied on 7 January 2011 for suspension under extreme urgency. Bruges first disputed its interest, since its bid was more expensive. Chamber president Dierk Verbiest rejected that objection: price was only one of three award criteria. Because the contract had been published after 24 February 2010, the Act of 23 December 2009 applied and a serious plea sufficed. On the merits, the Council recalled that it is not the classification in the specifications but the actual subject-matter and scope of the contract that determine whether the accreditation rules apply. Bruges argued that the contract was mainly digging, with archaeological supervision because of the site. The Council accepted that the excavation work was considerable — an estimated 80.347 m³ — but found that the contract clearly also included services. Under Directive 2004/18/EC, a contract covering both services and works is a services contract if the works are merely incidental. Here the contract appeared to be aimed mainly at archaeological research, at finding the least disruptive locations and at answering research questions; it was not even certain that the heating units would go into the planned pits. The bids confirmed this: for both tenderers, the specifically archaeological items made up most of the price, even more so for Monument Vandekerckhove than for Willaert. That the subsidising authority had made no comments on the specifications changed nothing. Moreover, Bruges had itself asked for restoration references and raised no objection to Willaert’s references, which mentioned excavations and archaeological trial-trench surveys. The accreditation rules therefore did not appear to apply, Willaert appeared to have been wrongly excluded, and it was no longer certain that the contract had gone to the most advantageous regular bid. In line with the opinion of first auditor Luc Vermeire, the Council suspended the decision of 23 December 2010.

Why does this matter?

Classifying a contract as works, supplies or services is not a label the contracting authority can choose freely. It determines which rules apply and, for works above the threshold, whether accreditation is required. This judgment shows how that goes wrong for a contract carried out on a building site but substantively consisting mainly of scientific work. Bruges reasoned from the estimate: two thirds of the money went to ‘pits and trenches’, so works, so category D. The Council looks beyond the largest item and asks what the contract really aims at. The specifications themselves spoke of an ‘archaeological excavation’ with research questions, recording, processing of finds and reporting, and the bidders priced those archaeological items higher than the estimate. The digging is therefore incidental and the accreditation requirement falls away. The judgment also confirms that an accreditation requirement in the specifications and notice does not automatically bind bidders: a bidder excluded for failing to meet a wrongly imposed accreditation can challenge that in proceedings against the exclusion and the award itself. And it is a reminder that a more expensive bidder keeps its interest as long as price is not the only award criterion.

The lesson

For contracting authorities: classify a mixed contract by its main subject-matter, not by the most expensive item in the estimate. Archaeological research, studies or supervision on a building site are not automatically works because digging is involved. Only require accreditation if the actual subject-matter calls for it, and then choose the category or subcategory that fits that subject-matter. If you want specialist skills, ask for them through selection criteria such as references and the deployment of an archaeologist — which Bruges in fact already did. For bidders: exclusion for lacking accreditation is not the end of the road. Check whether the contract really is a works contract, using the specifications themselves: the stated aim, the research questions and the price breakdown in the bids. Being more expensive does not deprive you of an interest if quality counts too.

Ask yourself

As an authority: what is the main subject-matter of your contract — the result you want to achieve, or the operations needed to get there? Did you choose an accreditation category because it fits the actual subject-matter, or because no better one existed? Does the price breakdown in the bids received still support the classification you chose in the specifications? As a bidder: are you being excluded on an accreditation that matches the actual subject-matter of the contract, or only the label the authority put on it? Can you show from the specifications themselves that the works are incidental to the services?

About this database

The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →