Care-home furniture for Aymonshof: a tie at 84 points, one recalculated point decides — and Bulvano loses its annulment action after almost seven years
The Dendermonde public social welfare centre (OCMW) saw Bulvano NV and Buro Project NV tie at 84 points for the furniture of the Aymonshof care home, awarded the contract to Buro Project, and after a remark by the VIPA replaced that decision with a new award based on a recalculated score for the delivery period (85 to 84); the Council of State held that Buro Project did not itself need to be registered because it put forward a registered subcontractor, that the points scales for aesthetics and completeness were reasonable, and that Bulvano’s criticism of the recalculation came too late.
What happened?
The OCMW of Dendermonde issued a general call for tenders for the supply and installation of loose and fixed furniture for the Aymonshof care home, published in the Bulletin der Aanbestedingen of 24 December 2003. Article 115 of the specifications set seven award criteria: price (30%), technical quality (20%), aesthetics (20%, to be assessed on the documentation and, ‘if necessary’, an optional showroom visit), delivery period (10%), completeness of the tender (10%), extra guarantees and continued availability (5%) and maintenance costs (5%). Nine tenders were opened on 11 February 2004. The award report of engineering firm Abetec of 5 March 2004 found a tie: Bulvano NV and Buro Project NV each had 84 points. After additional aesthetic examinations on 3 and 4 March 2004, Abetec recommended awarding the contract to Buro Project, given its lower price (877,149.50 euros against 899,117.92 euros excl. VAT), its shorter period for execution task 1 (42 against 65 calendar days) and its higher aesthetics score (19 against 14 out of 20). The OCMW awarded the contract to Buro Project on 12 March 2004, partly because the first phase of the new building would be finished at the end of April and the shell contractor could claim damages for delay. The VIPA, which had to approve the file, then indicated orally that the points for the delivery period had been miscalculated: 5 points for the shortest period, 0 for the longest and the rest by the rule of three. After recalculation Buro Project received 7 instead of 6 out of 10 for that criterion and reached 85 points, against an unchanged 84 for Bulvano. On 26 March 2004 the OCMW withdrew the first decision and again awarded the contract to Buro Project, now as the best-ranked tenderer. Bulvano learned on 29 April 2004 that it had not been awarded the contract and brought an annulment action on 28 June 2004; the judgment followed on 17 February 2011. The OCMW first disputed its interest, arguing that it only sought a declaration of unlawfulness with a view to a damages claim, but dropped that objection in its last brief. In a first plea Bulvano argued that Buro Project was not registered as a contractor, whereas article 90(5) of the Royal Decree of 8 January 1996 and article 92 of the specifications required this. The Council partly agreed: the fixed furniture (nurses’ station counter, built-in wardrobes, hanging profiles) was built-in bespoke work that became immovable by incorporation, so these were activities subject to registration. But under article 12(6) of the Law of 24 December 1993 a contractor is deemed to meet its tax and social-security obligations if its subcontractor is registered, and that presumption also applied to article 92 of the specifications. Buro Project had stated in its tender that it was not itself registered and had put forward ‘Keukens Redant’ as subcontractor, with a registration in the name of Redant Hedwig in category 20 (carpentry and joinery). The preliminary question Bulvano wanted referred about the difference with private contracts was, in the Council’s view, insufficiently substantiated. In its second plea Bulvano challenged the scoring. For ‘completeness’ it received 9 out of 10 and Buro Project 8, although the report said of Buro Project that there were ‘insufficient documents and data to arrive at a 100% compliant whole’; the Council found the scale (from 4 points for ‘very weak’ to 9 for ‘complete’) reasonable and the OCMW’s explanation plausible. For aesthetics (14 against 19 out of 20, Bulvano being ‘somewhat too modern for the intended residents’) the OCMW used a scale rising from 5 to 19 points, with larger steps at the top; the Council also found it relevant and reasonable, and the specifications expressly allowed showroom visits. The complaints that Buro Project had been able to complete its incomplete tender through those visits, and that the second calculation method for the delivery period was unusual and contrary to the specifications, came too late: Bulvano could already have raised them in its application or reply. For completeness the Council noted that Bulvano did not show why the first calculation would be more correct, and that an equal number of points was appropriate for total periods of 85 days (65 + 20) for Bulvano and 84 days (42 + 42) for Buro Project. The action was dismissed; Bulvano bears 175 euros in costs.
Why does this matter?
Three points make this old supply case still instructive. First, registration: whoever supplies and builds in fixed furniture carries out work on immovable property, but a tenderer that is not itself registered can cover this by putting forward a registered subcontractor — the presumption of article 12(6) of the Law of 24 December 1993 also applied here to specifications requiring registration of ‘the contractor’. Second, points scales: the Council reviews evaluation tables only marginally. A scale with larger steps at the top (16 to 19 out of 20), or verbal criticism that yields only a one-point difference, is not unreasonable as long as the method is relevant and applied consistently. Finally and above all: procedure. Bulvano’s strongest arguments — that its competitor could complete its tender through showroom visits, and that the recalculation of the delivery period was unusual — failed because they were only raised in a later brief, although the facts were already known. In a case where one recalculated point made the difference between a tie and a defeat, that weighs heavily.
The lesson
For bidders: after a narrow defeat, read the award report thoroughly at once and raise all complaints in your application. What you already knew when bringing the action cannot be added later; the Council declares such pleas late or inadmissible. Where there is a registration requirement, check whether the competitor puts forward a registered subcontractor — that generally suffices. For contracting authorities: fix points scales in advance and apply them consistently to all tenders; a verbal assessment that sounds harsher than the score must be explainable afterwards. Be careful with ‘corrections’ of the scoring after a first award: here the recalculation held, but only because the applicant did not challenge it in time. And state expressly in your specifications whether and how showroom visits count for a subjective criterion such as aesthetics.
Ask yourself
Do you raise all your complaints in your application, including those about how a criterion is calculated, or do you count on adding them later? Do you know that a tenderer that is not itself registered can meet a registration requirement through a registered subcontractor? Can you explain why a verbal assessment and a points score diverge? And as an authority: have you fixed your evaluation tables in advance, do you apply them consistently, and do your specifications expressly provide for showroom visits if you want to use them in the assessment?
About this database
The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →