An objection that comes back like a boomerang: Meerhout withdraws the award for its administrative centre, re-examines everything — and Vanhout.pro now wins by a wider margin
De Peuter NV first lost the shell construction of Meerhout’s new administrative centre by a mere 95.53 euros and its objection prompted a withdrawal of the award, but in the renewed examination the municipality accepted the quantity correction Vanhout.pro had made in its tender, widening the gap to 13,889.73 euros; the Council of State found no breach of legitimate expectations and no prohibited after-the-fact regularisation, and dismissed the application.
What happened?
The municipality of Meerhout put out a public tender (‘aanbesteding’) for lot 1 (shell construction, roofing, finishing, fixed furniture, limited site works, pilot contract) of the new building for its administrative centre, estimated at 3,046,843.45 euros excl. VAT and announced in the Bulletin der Aanbestedingen on 2 July 2010. At the opening on 27 August 2010 there were seven tenders: Vanhout.pro NV was lowest at 2,723,667.97 euros, De Peuter NV second at 2,764,634.30 euros. The dispute turned on article 10.17.34 of the specifications, ‘openings in interior safety glazing’: the bill of quantities provided lump-sum quantities of 116 pieces (phase 1) and 40 pieces (phase 2) for item 10.17.34A ‘openings for HVAC return air passage’, and 13 (phase 1) and 4 (phase 2) pieces each for the lead-throughs of items B and C. In its tender Vanhout.pro changed those quantities to 7 and 6 pieces for item A and to 3 pieces for items B and C in phase 2. In its tender report of 28 September 2010 the designer did not accept those changes and applied Vanhout.pro’s unit price to the quantities in the bill. After correction Vanhout.pro remained first at 2,783,636.32 euros, ahead of De Peuter at 2,783,731.85 euros — a difference of 95.53 euros. The college awarded the contract to Vanhout.pro on 11 October 2010. On 26 October 2010 De Peuter lodged an objection by registered letter against the calculations, mainly the application of the gap formula to Vanhout.pro’s missing price for item 00.07.30 ‘pilot contract’, but refrained at that time from seeking suspension. After consultations on 16 and 26 November 2010 the college withdrew the award on 6 December 2010, with a view to ‘a better reasoned and legally substantiated decision in the short term’. On 15 December 2010 Vanhout.pro was invited to a meeting about that withdrawal. There it objected in turn to the way the designer had inflated its price for item 10.17.34A, and explained on its own initiative that it had priced per wall unit: 13 passage units at 141 euros, 1,833 euros in total — equivalent to 11.75 euros per hole for the architect’s 156 openings. On 16 December 2010 the designer formally requested a price justification for items 10.17.33A and 10.17.34A, B and C, which Vanhout.pro provided the same day. The new tender report of 22 December 2010 accepted the per-room price for item 10.17.34A, because the total was comparable to the other bidders’ prices for all the holes; for items B and C the architect’s quantity still applied. As a result Vanhout.pro’s price for these items was 20,163 euros lower, and it ranked first at 2,769,842.12 euros against an unchanged 2,783,731.85 euros for De Peuter. On 27 December 2010 the college again awarded the contract to Vanhout.pro, for 2,766,917.78 euros excl. VAT. On 21 January 2011 De Peuter applied for suspension under extreme urgency. It argued that the assessment in the first report was final, that Vanhout.pro had never protested in time, and that the authority may not correct bidders’ errors after opening (art. 110 Royal Decree of 8 January 1996). The Council of State held that the withdrawal meant the first award decision is deemed never to have existed: the municipality was not bound by the reasons of the first report, and a new assessment may by definition lead to a different outcome. De Peuter could not legitimately expect the reassessment to produce the same result — all the more so because the withdrawal followed its own objection. The rules moreover expressly allow bidders to correct errors in lump-sum quantities (art. 96(2)), provided they attach a justification note, and oblige the authority to examine such corrections (art. 112). De Peuter did not dispute the soundness of that examination, relied on neither article 96 nor article 112, and did not specify which paragraph of article 110 had been breached. Vanhout.pro’s prices and quantities had not been changed either; they had merely been explained. The complaint about the gap formula was inadmissible because article 112 was not relied on, and in any event the new calculation had filled in the missing price for the pilot contract at a higher figure (28,651.85 euros instead of 22,283.05 euros), close to De Peuter’s own figure of 28,780.83 euros. The application was dismissed; De Peuter bears 175 euros in costs, Vanhout.pro 125 euros for its intervention.
Why does this matter?
The judgment shows sharply what a withdrawal means in law: the first award decision disappears as if it had never existed, and with it the reasons of the first tender report. A bidder who objects and prompts a withdrawal thereby reopens the entire assessment — including points decided in its favour. Here De Peuter first lost by 95.53 euros; after its own objection and the reassessment, that became 13,889.73 euros. The judgment also confirms that a bidder in a public tender may correct lump-sum quantities (art. 96(2) Royal Decree of 8 January 1996), that the authority must examine that correction, and that a price justification in which the bidder merely explains its own tender — without changing prices or quantities — is not a prohibited after-the-fact regularisation. Finally, it is a lesson in litigation: anyone who alleges a breach of ‘article 110’ in extreme-urgency proceedings without identifying the right paragraph, or criticises the gap formula without relying on article 112, will see those complaints fail.
The lesson
For bidders: think before prompting a withdrawal. After a withdrawal the authority may reassess everything, and your competitor gets the chance to raise its own complaints against the first report. If you find the lump-sum quantities in the specifications wrong, you may correct them in your tender, but you must attach a justification note — that saves debate later. And build your plea precisely: name the exact provision (here articles 96(2) and 112 rather than ‘article 110’) and make concrete what went wrong. For contracting authorities: a withdrawal within the time limit and before the contract is concluded is a legitimate remedy, and you are not bound by the reasons of the withdrawn decision. But make sure your new assessment actually examines the changed quantities as article 112 requires, that any price justification is requested in the forms article 110(3) prescribes, and that the bidder’s explanation clarifies rather than alters its tender.
Ask yourself
Do you realise that a withdrawn award decision is deemed never to have existed, so that in a new assessment the authority is not bound by earlier findings in your favour? If you correct lump-sum quantities in the bill, have you attached a justification note to your tender? Can you distinguish between explaining your tender in a price justification and altering it afterwards? Does your application name the exact provisions allegedly breached, including the right paragraph? And as an authority: do you genuinely examine quantity corrections proposed by bidders, and do you give reasons for accepting or rejecting them?
About this database
The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →