Suspension Dutch-speaking chamber

Half a point apart and not a word of explanation: the Council suspends the award of Flemish environmental analyses to Laboratorium ECCA because the VITO score tables stayed secret

Ruling nr. 211549 · 25 February 2011 · XIIe kamer

The temporary partnership of Labo Van Vooren and Al-West lost all five lots of the Flemish contract for measuring, sampling and analysing waste, soil and groundwater to Laboratorium ECCA by 98.1 to 100 points, but the Council of State suspended the award: for the 60-point quality criterion it was shown only VITO’s total scores, without the sub-scores and assessment tables, and the Flemish authority failed to show that confidentiality justified that silence — certainly not for the assessment of its own bid.

What happened?

The Environmental Inspectorate of the Flemish Department of Environment, Nature and Energy issued a general call for tenders for ‘measurement, sampling and analysis of waste, soil and groundwater’ (specification LNE/MI/2010/AFVAL/bis), advertised in the Bulletin of Tenders on 10 December 2010. The contract comprised five lots, one per province, and ran for four months. There were two award criteria: the quality of the technical performance (60 points) and the total price (40 points). For the quality criterion, bidders had to state for each of the 181 parameters in the inventory, among other things, which laboratory would carry out the analysis, within what time, which inter-laboratory tests it had taken part in, which accreditations it held, which z-scores it achieved in the OVAM ‘AARDE’ and ‘ORKA’ proficiency tests and which procedures it had. At the opening on 23 December 2010 there were two bids: one from Labo Van Vooren NV and Al-West BV, together a temporary partnership, and one from Laboratorium ECCA NV. The authority asked VITO to assess the quality criterion. VITO worked with six components (delivery times out of 5, proficiency tests under the accreditation schemes out of 60, voluntary proficiency tests out of 10, quality of analytical procedures out of 10, quality of procedures for sampling, storage and containers out of 10, accreditation out of 10) and on 10 January 2011 arrived at 63.81 out of 105 for ECCA and 63.30 out of 105 for the partnership. Converted: 60 against 59.52 points (rounded to 59.5 in the award report). On price ECCA scored 40 out of 40 in each lot, the partnership 38.6. Final score per lot: 100 against 98.1. By an undated decision — according to the authority’s note, of 23 January 2011 — the director-general awarded all five lots to ECCA. The partnership was informed on 26 January 2011 and the same day requested the reasoned award decision and the VITO report. It received the award report and VITO’s report, but without the table of scores per component and without the assessment tables; these were withheld as confidential business information and submitted to the Council only on a confidential basis. On 31 January 2011 the partnership sought suspension under the extreme urgency procedure. The Flemish Region first contested standing: the award had already been notified to ECCA, so the contract was concluded and a suspension could no longer benefit the applicants; without serious and irreparable harm, it argued, there could be no suspension. The Council swept this aside. The contract had been advertised after 24 February 2010, so the Act of 23 December 2009 applied. The new Article 65/15 of the Act of 24 December 1993 expressly removed the requirement of serious and irreparable harm, also below the EU threshold (Article 65/31) — the explanatory memorandum says so literally: suspension is possible ‘even if immediate enforcement […] would not cause serious harm that is difficult to repair’. Article 65/21 (concluded contract no longer suspendable) applies above the threshold, and the review body in Article 65/30 appears to be the ordinary courts. The argument that the plea lacked interest, since even bridging the full 0.5-point gap on quality the partnership would remain behind ECCA due to the 1.4-point price gap, also failed: without adequate reasoning a bidder cannot show not only that it scored too low, but also that the winner scored too high. On the merits, the Council held that ‘quality of the technical performance’ is a quintessentially qualitative criterion, for which a bare allocation of points is in principle insufficient. The partnership knew what had been assessed and by what method, and knew the total scores, but not the scores per component, nor how they were arrived at. For some components (proficiency tests, accreditation) the score seemed an arithmetical result it could recalculate itself, but even then it remained in the dark as to whether VITO had reached the same figure; for the two procedure components there was room for appreciation and no explanation at all. The confidentiality plea (Article 65/10(1)) did not convince: the Region did not show that all withheld data were confidential, confidentiality does not preclude a substantive assessment that takes it into account, and no objection was apparent to disclosing the full assessment of the applicants’ own bid. The single plea was serious. In the alternative, the Region asked for a balancing of interests: a suspension would leave the Inspectorate without measurements and analyses for months, the contract lasted only four months and a new twelve-month contract had already been advertised on 17 December 2010. The Council weighed it differently. A reasoning defect can be cured quickly, so the authority itself can limit the adverse effects in time; a suspension may give the applicants better insight into the assessment in a new decision; and the Region did not show that there were no other legal means to have urgent analyses carried out. The Council ordered the suspension of the award decision of 23 January 2011 and ordered the Flemish Region to pay the costs, set at EUR 350.

Why does this matter?

The judgment is a reference point for two reasons. First, it is an early and clear application of the remedies Act of 23 December 2009, which entered into force on 25 February 2010. The contracting authority tried to revive the old requirement of serious and irreparable harm by a detour: ‘the bidder need not prove it, but the Council may still review it’. The Council firmly rejected that reading, relying on the text and the legislative history, and confirmed that the rule also applies below the EU thresholds. That the contract had already been notified to the winner did not prevent suspension either, for a contract below the threshold. Second, the judgment sets the bar for reasoning on qualitative criteria assessed by an external expert. An authority may rely on VITO, but must then show bidders how VITO reached its figures. A total score with a list of what was assessed is not enough where the criterion leaves room for appreciation. Confidentiality is no watertight shield: the authority must show, item by item, why something may not be shared, and can in any event disclose the assessment of the unsuccessful bidder’s own bid. The case also shows how small the margins can be: half a point on quality and 1.4 points on price. Precisely with such narrow gaps every opaque sub-score matters, and precisely there the Council rejected the argument that the plea could make no difference. Three years later the Council suspended an award by the same department to the same laboratory for almost the same reason.

The lesson

For contracting authorities: by all means rely on an external expert, but incorporate its full assessment into your reasoning or disclose it. For qualitative criteria with room for appreciation, the unsuccessful bidder must be able to see, per component, what score it received and why. If you want to withhold data as confidential, justify that item by item and write a substantive assessment that does not reveal the confidential figures. And in any case give the unsuccessful bidder the full assessment of its own bid — there is rarely a valid objection to that. Nor should you assume that ‘concluding’ a below-threshold contract makes suspension impossible, or that a short duration automatically tips the balance of interests in your favour. For bidders: after notification, immediately request the full assessment report, including annexes and sub-scores, and document what you do not receive. A refusal to show the assessment of your own bid is a strong basis for a reasoning plea. Do not be deterred by a small points gap or by the argument that you ‘cannot win anyway’: as long as the reasoning does not allow you to check whether the winner rightly scored higher, you have an interest in the plea.

Ask yourself

As a contracting authority: does your award decision contain, for each qualitative criterion, the sub-scores and a short justification, even when an external expert did the assessment? When withholding data as confidential, have you justified item by item why disclosure would be harmful, and still communicated a substantive assessment? Have you given the unsuccessful bidder the full assessment of its own bid? As a bidder: after a rejection, have you requested all annexes and score tables of the assessment report, and recorded in writing what you did not receive? Do you know that in public procurement you no longer need to show serious and irreparable harm to obtain suspension under the extreme urgency procedure?

About this database

The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →