Iristeam’s WePulse framework agreement: the contract notice names the Council of State, but a non-profit association is not an authority — and Civadis pays the procedural indemnity
Civadis sought suspension under extreme urgency of the award by the non-profit association Iristeam to Sopra HR Software of a framework agreement for a single shared HR solution for Brussels local authorities, but the Council of State declared itself without jurisdiction because a non-profit that does not take unilaterally binding decisions towards third parties is not an administrative authority — the mention of the Council of State as review body in the contract notice changed nothing, and Civadis had to pay the 770-euro procedural indemnity.
What happened?
By a notice of 11 June 2025 in the Bulletin of Tenders, the non-profit association (ASBL) Iristeam launched a public contract to appoint a single integrator for the harmonisation and unification of the ‘Hard HR’ solutions of the local authorities of the Brussels-Capital Region into one common solution, under the WePulse programme (specifications CSC2025.014). It was a framework agreement, awarded through a competitive procedure with negotiation. On 1 September 2025 Iristeam selected three candidates: Cipal Schaubroeck, Civadis and Sopra HR Software France. Only Civadis and Sopra submitted a tender by 5 December 2025. Iristeam found irregularities in both tenders and let the bidders regularise them by 15 December 2025; Civadis, among other things, completed the matrix of functional and technical requirements and clarified its financial offer. On 16 December 2025 the bidders were invited to submit a ‘best and final offer’, limited to a price improvement. On 15 April 2026 Iristeam awarded the contract to Sopra as the most economically advantageous tender. Civadis went to the Council of State on 29 April 2026, but in a striking way: in its own application it argued that the Council lacked jurisdiction, and it acknowledged that it had brought a parallel action before the French-speaking Enterprise Court of Brussels — the application to the Council of State was filed ‘so as not to take any risk’ as to admissibility. Iristeam and Sopra, which intervened as the successful bidder, agreed; Iristeam added that the Court of Audit likewise does not regard it as an administrative authority. At the hearing Civadis changed tack and argued, relying on judgment no. 244.614 of 24 May 2019, that the Council could have jurisdiction because Iristeam had been set up by public authorities for a public-service mission. The presiding judge of the VIth chamber did not follow that view. Article 24 of the Act of 17 June 2013 gives jurisdiction to the Council of State only where the contracting authority is an authority within the meaning of article 14(1) of the coordinated laws on the Council of State; otherwise the ordinary courts have jurisdiction. Iristeam is a private-law non-profit association, set up outside any specific statutory framework, whose activity is governed by its articles of association and the Companies and Associations Code. A private-law legal person only becomes an administrative authority where it can and does take unilaterally binding decisions towards third parties; being created or controlled by public authorities, or entrusted with a public-interest mission, is not enough. Under settled case law, an award decision creates no obligations for third parties. That the notice on the e-Procurement platform named the Council of State as the ‘body responsible for review procedures’ was irrelevant: the tender guide and the award notification letter expressly designated the ordinary courts, and the rules on jurisdiction are a matter of public policy. The application was rejected. Civadis still claimed a procedural indemnity on the ground that the notice had misled it, but the Council saw no such error: the tender guide corrected the notice and itself provided that it prevailed over the notice in case of discrepancy. Iristeam does not have to bear the cost of Civadis’s procedural choice to seize the Council of State alongside the Enterprise Court. Civadis pays the 200-euro roll fee, the 26-euro contribution and a 770-euro procedural indemnity to Iristeam; Sopra bears its own 150-euro intervention fee and, as intervening party, receives no procedural indemnity.
Why does this matter?
The judgment confirms a line the Council of State has consistently held in recent years: not every contracting authority is an ‘authority’ for the Council of State. Non-profit associations, private-law subsidiaries and other structures bound by procurement law generally fall, for their award decisions, under the ordinary courts, because an award is not in itself a unilaterally binding decision towards third parties. For a joint body such as Iristeam, which steers IT services for Brussels local authorities, that is no detail: anyone wishing to challenge an award must go to the Enterprise Court in summary proceedings. The judgment also shows what an incorrect statement in the contract notice is worth: nothing, where the other procurement documents designate the correct court and themselves lay down their order of precedence. And it comes with a price tag: the ‘just in case’ proceedings before the Council of State cost Civadis the roll fee, the contribution and a 770-euro procedural indemnity, without its pleas ever being examined. Anyone in doubt about the competent court is well advised to resolve that doubt thoroughly in advance rather than seizing two courts at once.
The lesson
As a bidder, check for every contracting authority that is not a classic public body — a non-profit association, a cooperative, a private-law subsidiary — whether it can take unilaterally binding decisions towards third parties. If not, the ordinary courts have jurisdiction and you must go to the Enterprise Court in summary proceedings. Do not rely blindly on the review body named in the contract notice: read the tender guide, the specifications and the award notification letter, and check which document prevails in case of discrepancy. An application to the Council of State filed ‘just in case’ is not free: if the Council declares itself without jurisdiction, you pay the other side’s procedural indemnity. As a contracting authority in private-law form, make sure the notice, the tender guide and the notification letter name the same review body and set a clear order of precedence in the documents; that avoids confusion and disputes over costs.
Ask yourself
Do you know, for each contracting authority you deal with, whether it is an administrative authority for the Council of State or whether the ordinary courts hear challenges to its award decisions? When an award is notified, do you check whether the notice, the tender guide and the notification letter name the same review body — and which document prevails in case of conflict? Have you factored in that a Council of State without jurisdiction will make you pay the other side’s procedural indemnity? As a contracting authority organised as a non-profit association: does your e-Procurement notice name the correct review body, or are you relying on your other documents to correct the error?
About this database
The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →