Rejection Dutch-speaking chamber

‘Engie/Fluvius is not a public body’: a bidder that worked as Engie’s subcontractor has no reference for a public client

Ruling nr. 267094 · 18 June 2026 · XIVe kamer

NV M. was not selected by the city of Nieuwpoort for the supply of charging stations because none of its references had been performed for a ‘public body’; the Council of State held that it made no difference that this requirement appeared only in the specifications and not in the contract notice, since M. knew the specifications and had itself responded to them, and that a reference as a subcontractor of Engie — even though Engie was performing a framework contract for Fluvius — is not a reference for a public body, and dismissed the extreme-urgency application.

What happened?

The city of Nieuwpoort launched an open procedure for a public supply contract for the ‘Supply and installation of charging stations and provision of a charge management platform’ (specifications TD-OD-D2025-13), a price-list contract with price as the sole award criterion. The contract was published nationally on 5 January 2026. The notice in the Bulletin der Aanbestedingen asked, as a selection criterion, for a list of the main supplies of the last three years ‘stating the amount, the date and the public or private recipients’, with a minimum of three references. The specifications went further: one reference had to be for a public body and one had to include at least 15 charging stations under management. By 5 February 2026, 17 companies had submitted offers, including NV M. It relied on a specialised subcontractor whose ‘Reference 1 (Public charging points)’ concerned the installation of public charging stations for Engie. On 26 February 2026 the city e-mailed a request for missing information on the references, warning that the offer would otherwise no longer be considered. On 3 March 2026 M. replied that ‘something had gone wrong’ when bundling the documents and sent the three references separately: two for private clients (IKEA and Friesland Campina) and a third in which the subcontractor had worked as a regular subcontractor of Engie, which had won Fluvius’s latest RFP for the roll-out of public charging stations in Flemish municipalities. In its review report of 24 April 2026 the city did not accept that reference. On 4 May 2026 the board of mayor and aldermen approved the report and awarded the contract to NV B., which offered the lowest regular price. The notification of 6 May 2026 was brief: ‘No valid reference from a public body (Engie/Fluvius is not a public body)’. On 21 May 2026 M. sought suspension under extreme urgency. The city first disputed its interest: even if selected, M. would with its ‘considerably higher’ price only rank fourth. The Council rejected that objection: if a plea were serious, the selection would have to be redone, possibly for other non-selected bidders too, and that outcome could not be anticipated. On the merits, M.’s first plea argued that the requirement of a reference for a public body appeared only in the specifications, not in the notice, whereas article 65 of the Royal Decree of 18 April 2017 requires selection criteria to be stated in the notice. The Council read that provision in light of its purpose: transparency and equal treatment, so that bidders can decide with equal knowledge whether and how to submit an offer. That purpose had been achieved here. The notice already referred to public or private clients and referred to the contract documents in several places; M. did not dispute that it knew the specifications before submitting, it had itself listed a ‘Public charging points’ reference, and after the request of 26 February it had supplemented its documents without any objection. It showed no disadvantage compared with other bidders. In its second plea M. argued that Fluvius — the umbrella name of nine Flemish inter-municipal associations — is indeed a public body, and that, absent a definition in the specifications, the term had to be interpreted broadly and in the bidder’s favour. The Council accepted that Fluvius may be a public client, but that was beside the point: the documents showed that the reference had been performed ‘for Engie’, and neither the offer, nor the clarification of 3 March, nor the application showed to what extent Fluvius was involved in the work or that Engie itself was a public body. M. itself had written that its subcontractor worked for Engie. Its criticism of the price review — the report stated its total amount with a difference of 0.11 euros — and of the prices of the successful bidder failed for lack of interest: a bidder rightly not selected is no longer assessed on substance. Of its own motion the Council noted that the city had quoted in its brief from the e-mail of 3 March filed as confidential, but that M. had already quoted from it in its own application; the Council assumed that M. no longer maintained confidentiality on that point. The application was dismissed. M. bears 200 euros in roll fees, a 26-euro contribution and a 770-euro procedural indemnity to the city of Nieuwpoort.

Why does this matter?

The judgment touches on two questions that arise regularly in practice. The first is formal: what if a selection requirement appears in the specifications but not (or less strictly) in the contract notice? Article 65 of the Royal Decree of 18 April 2017 is clear, but the Council does not apply it mechanically. It looks at the purpose of the rule — transparency and equal treatment — and asks whether the bidder was actually disadvantaged. A bidder that knew the specifications, tailored its offer to them and simply supplemented its documents after a request for clarification can hardly argue afterwards that it was caught out by the discrepancy. The second question is substantive and at least as useful: does work you performed as a subcontractor for a private main contractor count as a reference ‘for a public body’ because the main contractor in turn worked for a public client? Prima facie, no. The Council looks at who the client of the reference is, and that was Engie, not Fluvius. The public nature of the end client is not enough without concrete documents on the link with that end client. The judgment also confirms that a low price ranking does not automatically deprive a non-selected bidder of its interest: if the selection has to be redone, the field may change too. Finally, the remark on confidential documents returns that the same 14th chamber made on the same day in the De Vlaamse Waterweg judgment (no. 267.102) — with the nuance that a party which itself quotes from a confidential document gives up its confidentiality request on that point.

The lesson

For bidders: read the selection requirements in the specifications, not just in the notice, and check for each reference who was legally the client. If you worked as a subcontractor, your client is the main contractor, not its customer. If you want the public nature of the end client to count, supply the documents proving the link in the offer itself (certificates from the public client, the framework agreement, your subcontractor’s role in it). A discrepancy between notice and specifications is best raised before submission through a question to the authority; a bidder that simply plays along will struggle to rely on it later. And do not quote yourself from documents for which you request confidentiality. For authorities: include selection requirements fully and identically in the notice and in the specifications, even if the purpose of the rule saved you here. Define terms such as ‘public body’ or ‘public client’ if you attach a distinction to them, and say whether references as a subcontractor count. A targeted request for clarification with a clear deadline and sanction, as Nieuwpoort sent, makes the subsequent selection decision robust.

Ask yourself

As a bidder: who was legally the client of each reference you list — the end client or the main contractor for whom you worked as a subcontractor? Does your offer contain documents that concretely prove the public nature of the client and your link with it, if the specifications require a reference for a public body? Did you flag a difference between the selection criteria in the notice and in the specifications before submitting, or did you silently follow the strictest criterion? As an authority: are your selection requirements stated fully and identically in the notice and in the specifications? Have you defined terms such as ‘public body’ and specified whether references from subcontracting are accepted?

About this database

The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →