Rejection French-speaking chamber

Foyer Schaerbeekois admits a selection error and withdraws its renovation award: Yvo Rinaldi’s urgent application inadmissible, but the contracting entity pays

Ruling nr. 267280 · 29 June 2026 · VIe kamer

After Les Entreprises Yvo Rinaldi sought the suspension of the award of a framework agreement for light renovation of flats in Schaerbeek, Foyer Schaerbeekois withdrew that award because of an error in applying the selection criteria and re-awarded the contract, this time including Rinaldi; the application thus became inadmissible, but because the withdrawal counts as a disguised annulment — and the award had never been notified to Rinaldi — Foyer Schaerbeekois had to bear the 770-euro procedural indemnity and the costs.

What happened?

On 23 April 2026 Foyer Schaerbeekois awarded contract no. 2025.SEM-FPE-001, a works framework agreement for ‘the light renovation of flats located in the municipality of Schaerbeek’, to three contractors: Slavi Ivanov, Ecobel Construct and A.R.T. Building Group. The tender of Les Entreprises Yvo Rinaldi was ranked fourth and thus missed out. According to Rinaldi, the award decision was never notified to it; it only learned of it through a link on the BOSA platform. On 4 June 2026 it applied to the Council of State for suspension under extreme urgency. Ecobel Construct intervened as beneficiary on 17 June 2026. One day later, on 18 June 2026, Foyer Schaerbeekois withdrew the contested decision. It expressly acknowledged that it had made an error in applying the selection criteria and, in the same instrument, re-awarded the framework agreement, now to Ecobel Construct, A.R.T. Building Group and Rinaldi. At the hearing of 22 June 2026 Rinaldi acknowledged that, in view of current case law, its application no longer met the conditions of articles 14 and 15 of the Act of 17 June 2013. The Council agreed: the withdrawal operates retroactively to the date of the contested decision, so the alleged breaches — assuming they existed — neither harmed Rinaldi nor risked harming it. One of the admissibility conditions of article 14 was therefore not met, and the Council did not need to address other possible grounds for rejection, such as whether Foyer Schaerbeekois is an administrative authority at all and whether the Council had jurisdiction. Rinaldi itself conceded at the hearing that the action had wrongly been brought before the Council of State, but argued that the mistake was explained by the fact that the decision had never been notified to it, so it had never been informed of the available remedies. Foyer Schaerbeekois did not dispute this and filed no administrative file showing otherwise. Decisive for the Council, moreover, was that Foyer Schaerbeekois withdrew its decision while the action was pending, when it could not have been unaware that the Council lacked jurisdiction, and in doing so acknowledged its own error. In those particular circumstances — and notwithstanding the jurisdictional question — the Council treated the withdrawal as a disguised annulment: Foyer Schaerbeekois is the losing party and Rinaldi the prevailing party. The application was dismissed, Rinaldi’s tender (exhibit 10) remained confidential, and Foyer Schaerbeekois was ordered to pay the roll fee of 200 euros, the contribution of 26 euros and a procedural indemnity of 770 euros. Ecobel Construct bears only its 150-euro intervention fee.

Why does this matter?

The judgment first confirms a strict admissibility rule: if the contracting entity withdraws the contested award decision, the requirement of ‘having been or being at risk of being harmed’ under article 14 of the Remedies Act disappears retroactively, and an urgent application becomes inadmissible. More interesting is what the Council does with the costs. Normally, whoever brings an action before a court that probably lacks jurisdiction bears the consequences. Here the Council reversed that, because the contracting entity had caused the mistake: the award decision had never been notified to the unsuccessful bidder, so it had never received the statement of available remedies. On top of that, Foyer Schaerbeekois, knowing the action was before the wrong court, nevertheless withdrew its decision and acknowledged its own selection error. The Council expressly left the jurisdictional question open, but saw the withdrawal as a substitute for annulment. The message to contracting entities is clear: whoever neglects the duty to notify and then corrects its own error cannot hide behind a procedural mistake by the bidder that it helped bring about. For bidders it is a reminder that a withdrawn award, especially when you end up among the new winners, ends your proceedings — but not necessarily at your expense.

The lesson

As a contracting entity, always formally notify the award decision to all bidders, stating the available remedies and the competent court. If you fail to do so, you bear the risk that a bidder goes to the wrong court — and that you get the bill for it. If you discover an error in the selection while an action is pending, withdrawing and deciding afresh is the right reflex, but expect to bear the costs as the losing party. If you are a bidder and only learn of an award through a publication platform, document exactly when and how you learned of it, and check who is awarding the contract: where an entity’s status as an administrative authority is doubtful, the ordinary courts may be the competent forum. And if the contracting entity withdraws its decision, you may freely concede that your application has become inadmissible — but claim your procedural indemnity.

Ask yourself

As a contracting entity, have you notified the award decision to all bidders, stating the available remedies and the competent court? As a bidder, do you know whether the entity awarding the contract is an administrative authority, and therefore whether you must go to the Council of State or to the ordinary courts? Do you realise that withdrawal of the contested decision retroactively removes your interest, so that your urgent application becomes inadmissible? Can you show how and when you learned of the award, if it was never notified to you? As a contracting entity, do you know that withdrawing a decision after an action has been brought, while acknowledging your own error, can leave you with the procedural indemnity and the costs — even if the Council possibly lacked jurisdiction?

About this database

The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →