A van without fuel costs, a subcontractor who disappears from the price justification and a wage basis nobody checked: Council of State suspends Verviers’ award of its street-cleaning contract to Laurenty
The city of Verviers awarded the cleaning of its town centre (estimated at EUR 620,040 excluding VAT) to Laurenty Espaces Verts and accepted its suspiciously low and high unit prices after a 21-page price justification, but the Council of State suspended the award at the request of Oupeye Voirie Services because the file showed no careful price examination: the city had not checked which joint committee the winner’s labour costs were based on, and overlooked that its price justification denied subcontracting that its bid did declare, and included no depreciation, maintenance, insurance or fuel for a van, nor depreciation or maintenance for cleaning carts.
What happened?
On 19 March 2026 the Verviers city council decided to tender the public cleaning of the town centre and approved specifications MP2026-006. The contract, estimated at EUR 620,040 excluding VAT (EUR 750,248.40 including VAT), was tendered by open procedure and published on 23 March 2026 in the Official Journal and nationally. Four bids were received. The city found apparently abnormal prices in the bids of SRL Oupeye Voirie Services (OVS) and Laurenty Espaces Verts and asked both for justifications; Laurenty replied with a 21-page document. Following a report of 7 May 2026, the municipal executive awarded the contract on 12 May 2026 to Laurenty as the regular bid with the best price-quality ratio; OVS came second and was informed by letter of 13 May. On 28 May 2026 OVS sought suspension in extreme urgency, arguing that the city had accepted Laurenty’s abnormal prices — according to OVS, up to 41.01% below average for item 4, 34.96% for item 9, 40.26% for item 19 and 39.26% for item 20, and 80.47% above for item 13 — without concrete checks and with stereotyped reasoning. State councillor Florence Piret, acting president of the VIth chamber in summary proceedings, started with the wage basis. The price revision clause linked quarterly revision to the average hourly wage ((2 x 1A + 1 x 1B) / 3) set by joint committee 121 for cleaning and required tenderers to ‘detail and justify’ their staff in those categories in their bids. OVS had done so and expressly referred to JC 121; Laurenty only gave a staff list and mentioned its joint committee in its price justification; the tenderers together cited different joint committees, contradicting the premise of the specifications. Since labour costs are a main price component, the city had at least to examine this and its impact on the price check; neither the decision nor the file showed it had, and explanations given afterwards in its observations could not cure this. OVS had an interest in the complaint, even if the wage differences might be limited. On the price justification itself, the file contained nothing but the award decision and the report: no comparative price table, no averages, no unit price estimate. The Council noted large price gaps between OVS and Laurenty for almost all items, and that OVS had left one inventory item blank without the city querying it. The city argued that confidentiality allowed brief reasoning; the Council agreed that reasoning may be brief, even allusive, but not excessively laconic. Reading Laurenty’s justification revealed at least three issues: it stated that Laurenty did not use subcontracting, whereas its bid said otherwise and relied on a third party’s capacity for part of the services, which appeared nowhere in the price breakdown; several items provided for a flatbed van with raised sides without any depreciation, maintenance, insurance or fuel in the price structure, although such costs were included for other vehicles; and cleaning carts had no depreciation or maintenance. These should have caught the city’s attention and required fuller reasoning or at least a confidential explanatory document in the file. The plea was serious; the city identified no adverse consequences of suspension and the Council saw none. The award was suspended, the bids and justifications kept confidential and costs reserved. First auditor Muriel Vanderhelst concurred.
Why does this matter?
The judgment shows how the Council applies its marginal review of abnormal prices: it does not decide whether a price is normal, but it does read the justification and checks whether the authority asked the obvious questions. A 21-page justification is no blank cheque if it contradicts the bid or omits costs for equipment the tenderer itself relies on. It also exposes a less obvious pitfall: a price revision formula tied to one joint committee assumes all tenderers use those wage scales; if they do not, the comparability of labour costs — and thus the price check — is at stake. Finally, confidentiality justifies brief reasoning only if the examination can be found in a confidential document in the file; explanations given later do not count.
The lesson
Contracting authorities: read a price justification for substance, not length. Compare it with the bid, check that every resource deployed has a cost in the price build-up, verify the wage basis where your specifications refer to a joint committee, and record your analysis — a comparative price table and a confidential note — in the file. Tenderers: where price gaps are large, request the file and check whether the winner’s price examination is actually visible; point to concrete gaps or contradictions rather than to the price differences themselves, and make sure your own bid is complete and consistent.
Ask yourself
As an authority: did you compare each price justification with the bid and spot contradictions on subcontracting, staff or equipment? Does every vehicle and piece of equipment have a cost in the price build-up? Have you checked the wage basis each tenderer uses? Does your file contain a comparative price table and a record of your examination? As a tenderer: can you point to specific costs or statements the authority failed to examine, and is your own bid complete and consistent?
About this database
The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →