Laboratory furniture remains a supply contract, even within a EUR 31 million building project: Potteau fails to suspend the University of Liège’s award on the ground that the winner lacked contractor accreditation
SA Potteau lost lot 2 ‘laboratory furniture’ (estimated at EUR 2.76 million) of the renovation of the University of Liège’s chemistry building B6a by 83.35 to 86.3 points and argued that the lot was a works contract requiring the winner to hold contractor accreditation, but the Council of State held that each lot must be classified on its own, that this lot is essentially a supply contract with ancillary installation — despite tender documents that repeatedly used works terminology — and that the sub-criteria weighted after the fact for the maintenance criterion also passed muster.
What happened?
The University of Liège tendered, by open procedure, the ‘restructuring of chemistry building B6a’ (reference 2512T/POE): a heavy renovation including demolition down to the concrete structure, new façades, windows and roofs, conversion of the west wing into laboratories and the north wing into offices, and redevelopment of the surroundings. Lot 1 (demolition, structural work, finishing and special techniques) was estimated at EUR 28,168,027 excluding VAT and required accreditation in category D, class 8. Lot 2 (laboratory furniture) was estimated at EUR 2,764,444 excluding VAT, had its own specifications and required at least two references for the ‘supply and installation of laboratory furniture and equipment’, but no accreditation. It was assessed on price, fume cupboard performance and maintenance. Potteau bid only for lot 2. Of four bids, two were declared irregular; in the evaluation report of 3 May 2026 the successful tenderer, not named in the judgment, scored 86.3 points and Potteau 83.35. The award of 13 May 2026 was sent to Potteau by registered letter on 19 May, and Potteau sought suspension in extreme urgency on 2 June 2026. It argued first that lot 2, as part of a major renovation, was a works contract, so that the winner needed accreditation and the specifications were unlawful for not requiring it, pointing to the works CPV code, the safety and health plan, the requested certificates of satisfactory performance and the works terminology in the documents. State councillor Florence Piret, sitting in summary proceedings as acting president of the VIth chamber, reviewed the classification in full, since an authority has no discretion on it. The classification of the overall project and of lot 1 says nothing about lot 2, which must be assessed separately. Under Article 20 of the Law of 17 June 2016 — a supply contract with ancillary installation remains a supply contract — and on a set of indications, she held prima facie that lot 2 was a supply contract: the technical clauses described products in detail (fume cupboards, benches, sinks, base cabinets, shelving, chemical safety cabinets, taps, extraction arms); the modular furniture only needed to be installed and connected to utility points laid by the lot 1 contractor, with installation included in the furniture prices rather than listed as separate items in the bill of quantities; selection required supply-and-installation references, not accreditation; and the award criteria assessed the furniture, not the installation. The ‘clumsy drafting’ — with a CPV code both parties considered wrong and a 6% VAT rate the university considered wrong — showed ‘a certain confusion’, but classification depends on the objective application of the law, not on the authority’s intention or errors. The safety and health plan was explained by the lot 1 works site, and the outdated definition in Article 1 of the Royal Decree of 26 September 1991 no longer applies. Potteau’s alternative complaint that the confused specifications were unlawful anyway failed for lack of interest: it had been able to bid without accreditation and did not show any concrete harm; harm is required even where a rule of public policy is at stake, and the chance of winning a re-tender is not enough. The second plea targeted the ‘maintenance’ criterion, for which the specifications listed three unweighted assessment elements. The evaluation scored each out of 10 and converted the total into the criterion’s 10 points. The Council accepted that these had become weighted sub-criteria but, applying CJEU case law including Evropaïki Dynamiki/EMSA, found that equal weighting — ‘the most predictable’ — did not alter the criterion, could not have influenced the bids and was not discriminatory. The reasoning, ‘admittedly succinct’, was sufficient: it identified a weakness in Potteau’s bid (adding utilities required drilling the monobloc casing) and a strength (technical quality ‘above standard’, though mainly concerning the inner tank), explaining its score of 6.3 out of 10. Judgment no. 263,012, relied on by Potteau, concerned an incoherent evaluation method and was not relevant. The application was dismissed, the bids remained confidential and costs were reserved. Auditor Pacôme Noumair concurred.
Why does this matter?
The judgment offers a clear method for a recurring question in building projects with fit-out lots: is supplying and installing fixed furniture or equipment a works or a supply contract? Each lot is classified on its own; classification is objective and fully reviewed; and works terminology, a works CPV code or a 6% VAT rate in the documents do not change the nature of the contract. The Council looks at the actual services: what the technical clauses describe, whether installation is priced separately, and what the selection and award criteria assess. It also confirms its strict line on interest: even a breach of a public-policy rule such as contractor accreditation must have concretely harmed the applicant. Finally, it confirms that unweighted assessment elements may be weighted equally afterwards, and that brief but concrete reasoning per element suffices.
The lesson
Contracting authorities: decide deliberately, lot by lot, whether you are buying works, supplies or services, and draft consistently; inconsistent CPV codes, VAT rates or references did not change the classification here, but they did invite litigation. Announce weightings in advance, and give concrete reasons per element. Tenderers: a classification argument is not won with drafting slips or with the nature of the overall project; look at what the lot actually requires and how the bill of quantities is built. To challenge unlawful specifications, show concretely how they harmed the preparation of your bid.
Ask yourself
As an authority: did you classify each lot separately on the basis of what it actually requires, and do the CPV code, VAT rate and selection criteria match? Is installation priced separately or included in the supply? Did you announce the weighting of sub-criteria, or can you justify an ex post weighting? As a tenderer: does your classification argument rest on the actual services rather than on terminology, and can you show concrete harm from any flaw in the specifications?
About this database
The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →