Rejection French-speaking chamber

SPGE withdraws its award for energy management of water treatment plants before the hearing: Xylem’s application is inadmissible, but SPGE bears all the costs

Ruling nr. 267311 · 30 June 2026 · VIe kamer

After the Walloon Société publique de gestion de l’eau awarded its EUR 117,890 contract for the energy and functional management of four water infrastructures to Purecontrol BE and Xylem Water Solutions France sought suspension in extreme urgency, SPGE withdrew the award a week later; the Council of State declared the application inadmissible because a retroactively withdrawn decision could no longer harm Xylem, but ordered SPGE to pay the EUR 770 procedural indemnity and the other costs.

What happened?

The Société publique de gestion de l’eau (SPGE) tendered a services contract, reference MP24.038, under an open procedure with EU publication, for the energy and functional management of the installations and equipment of three wastewater treatment infrastructures and one drinking water production infrastructure. On 21 May 2026 its management committee awarded the contract to SRL Purecontrol BE, based in Liège, for EUR 117,890 excluding VAT, rather than to the French company Xylem Water Solutions France. Xylem sought suspension in extreme urgency on 11 June 2026; Purecontrol BE applied to intervene on 19 June. On 18 June 2026 SPGE’s management committee withdrew the contested award and informed the Council of State on 23 June; the judgment does not say why. At the hearing of 26 June 2026 Xylem’s counsel left the consequences of the withdrawal to the Council’s discretion; SPGE and Purecontrol BE, though duly summoned, were not represented. State councillor Aurélien Vandeburie admitted the intervention, as the successful tenderer had sufficient interest. The application itself was inadmissible: Article 15 of the Law of 17 June 2013 refers to the conditions of Article 14, which require that the applicant has been or risks being harmed by the alleged breach. Because the withdrawal is retroactive to the date of the contested decision, the alleged illegalities, even if proven, could not have harmed Xylem. The application was dismissed. On costs, however, SPGE was treated as the losing party under Article 30/1 of the coordinated laws because of the withdrawal: it was ordered to pay Xylem the basic procedural indemnity of EUR 770 as well as the EUR 200 court fee and the EUR 26 contribution, while Purecontrol BE bore its EUR 150 intervention fee. Auditor Philippe Nicodème concurred.

Why does this matter?

The judgment follows a line the Council of State consistently applied in 2026: when the authority withdraws the contested decision before judgment, the urgent application is not ‘without object’ but inadmissible, because the applicant is no longer harmed within the meaning of Article 14. In practice the applicant still achieves its aim — the award is gone — and, more importantly, it is treated as the winning party for costs, so the authority pays the procedural indemnity, the court fee and the contribution. The intervening successful tenderer pays its own fee. And a withdrawal does not end the contest: a new decision must follow, which can in turn be challenged.

The lesson

Contracting authorities: a prompt withdrawal can avoid a suspension, but you will pay the costs; it is cheaper to test the award properly beforehand or to act on a reasoned objection before the tenderer goes to court. Unsuccessful tenderers: a timely, well-argued application can bring the authority to reconsider, at its expense — but follow the new decision closely. Successful tenderers: intervening makes sense, but you bear the intervention fee even if the award is withdrawn.

Ask yourself

As an authority: did you promptly assess whether the contested award holds, and notify any withdrawal immediately? Is your new decision independently and adequately reasoned? As an unsuccessful tenderer: did you expressly claim a procedural indemnity, and are you ready to challenge a new decision in time? As the successful tenderer: have you factored in the cost of intervening?

About this database

The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →