95 versus 94.88: narrowly losing the Mortsel street-tree pruning contract gives no right to a second round, and three ‘forgotten’ tender elements do not make the reasoning defective
BV B. lost the framework agreement for pruning street trees in Mortsel to NV K. by 94.88 to 95 points because it scored 8 instead of 10 out of 10 on the equipment criterion; the Council of State held that the evaluation report adequately explained that difference, that selectively cited omissions from the tender do not change this, and that Article 87(2) of the Royal Decree on award procedures applies only to tenders considered equal — not to a small difference — and dismissed the urgent suspension application.
What happened?
The city of Mortsel tendered, under an open procedure with national and European publication, a services framework agreement for periodic pruning of street trees in 2026-2030 (specifications ‘2026 D 14’). The award criteria were price over four years (40 points), work plan (30), working methods and techniques for annual, biennial and triennial pruning cycles applied to specific streets (20), and ‘technical value and quality of materials and equipment’ (10), the latter covering available machinery, sustainable materials management and low-noise equipment. Qualitative criteria were scored on a scale from ‘excellent’ (100%) to ‘no description’ (0%). Of three tenders, BV B. and NV K. were both selected and found regular in the evaluation report of 20 May 2026. B. scored 36.88 on price, 30, 20 and 8: 94.88 in total. K. scored 40, 27, 18 and 10: 95. B. did better on the work plan and methods, K. on price; the fourth criterion tipped the balance: K. was rated ‘excellent’ for, among other things, its own partly renewed fleet, biodegradable fuels such as Aspen, solar-panelled vans, an electric Unimog and replacing diesel with HVO 100; B. was rated ‘good’ for exclusively electric chainsaws and hedge trimmers, biodegradable chain and hydraulic oils, EURO 6 vehicles, electric cargo bikes and regular fleet renewal. The college awarded the contract to K. on 26 May 2026. B.’s request of 6 June to withdraw the award was refused on 10 June, and on 11 June 2026 B. sought suspension in extreme urgency; K. intervened. B. first argued that three elements of its tender — its use of Aspen fuel, annual evaluation of its fleet and waste handling — were ignored. State councillor Kaat Leus disagreed: criticism cannot rest on selectively quoted parts of the reasoning, which must be adequate as a whole; an element not mentioned may simply not have warranted a plus or minus; annual fleet evaluation was already covered by ‘regular fleet renewal’; it was unclear whether the Aspen-fuelled machines would be used at all, since B. announced electric chainsaws only; and waste handling fell under the third criterion, where B. scored 20/20. B. then argued that with a ‘0.22-point’ gap — the scores in the report actually show 0.12 — the tenders were equally advantageous, so Article 87(2) required the city to invite price reductions or improvements. That failed too: the ranking determines the most economically advantageous tender, Article 87(2) applies only where tenders are considered equal, a small difference remains a difference, and B. did not substantiate its broader reading. The application was dismissed; B. was ordered to pay the court fee of EUR 200, a EUR 26 contribution and a EUR 770 procedural indemnity to the city, and K. its EUR 150 intervention fee.
Why does this matter?
Two questions that arise in every close award get a clear answer. First, how detailed must reasoning on a qualitative criterion be? Not so detailed that every element of every tender must be named: the evaluation report must show the tenders were assessed against the elements in the specifications and why one scored better. A losing tenderer that merely points to omissions, without showing they made the overall assessment unreasonable, will not succeed — and only elements relevant to this contract and to the contested criterion count. Second, does a minimal points gap open a ‘second chance’ under Article 87(2)? No: it is a tie-breaker for equal tenders, not a correction mechanism for a small deficit.
The lesson
Tenderers: challenging a qualitative score requires more than listing what the evaluation report leaves out. Show that the elements are relevant to this contract, belong under the contested criterion and should have tipped the overall assessment — and write your tender so the link to the contract is visible. Losing by a fraction of a point gives no right to an improvement round. Contracting authorities: a report that names each tender’s strengths per criterion and links the score to the announced scale will hold, even without repeating every detail — but be consistent in what you weigh for each tenderer.
Ask yourself
Does your tender give, for each qualitative criterion, concrete information about what you will deploy for this contract? Is each strength placed under the right criterion? In a challenge, can you show that an unmentioned element should have changed the overall score? Do you know Article 87(2) applies only to equal tenders? And as an authority: does your evaluation report name the strengths and weaknesses of each tender per criterion?
About this database
The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →