Rejection Dutch-speaking chamber

Fourteen years of data centre services for Fluvius: a term well beyond the eight years of the utilities sectors stands, because a data centre migration is complex and must keep pace with server renewal

Ruling nr. 267333 · 2 July 2026 · XIVe kamer

NV D., subcontractor of the incumbent provider, challenged the second award of Fluvius’s ‘Housing Datacenter’ contract to NV L., arguing that a fourteen-year term exceeds the eight-year guideline in Article 135 of the Law of 17 June 2016 and that the ‘services offered’ and ‘CO2 neutrality’ criteria assessed the tenderer rather than the tender, but the Council of State held that the term was adequately justified by the complexity of a migration and its alignment with server renewal, read the award criteria together with the technical specifications, and dismissed the urgent suspension application.

What happened?

Fluvius System Operator sought a provider to supply and manage data centre services across several independent Tier 3 data centres, through a negotiated procedure with prior call for competition in the utilities sectors (specifications FLU24IT010_2), published nationally and in the EU on 10 July 2025. A strategy report, apparently approved by the board on 26 March 2025, opted for a fourteen-year term with a unilateral termination right from year six, citing the complexity and business impact of a possible migration lasting 18 to 24 months. Of five applicants, four were selected and three submitted tenders, followed by negotiations and best and final offers. Fluvius awarded the contract to NV L. on 25 February 2026, withdrew that decision on 19 March 2026 after NV D. sought suspension (the first proceedings were closed by judgment no. 266.637 of 11 May 2026), re-evaluated the final offers and awarded the contract to L. again on 20 May 2026. The new award report explained that the award means leaving the existing sites in Oostkamp and Merelbeke, set out a transition phase (up to six months) and a transformation phase (12 to 24 months), and put the eight-year net present value at -EUR 5.886 million, including EUR 3.2 million in migration costs, against -EUR 9.086 million if a second migration were needed after year six; fourteen years also matches the five-to-six-year server renewal cycle. D., a subcontractor of the incumbent N., whose contract also ran for fourteen years, sought suspension again on 5 June 2026. State councillor Inge Vos rejected the first plea: the reasons for the longer term were adopted before publication in the strategy report, the award report merely elaborated on them, Article 135 does not require them to appear in the procurement documents, and the possibility of a migration was clear from the documents — a selection reference for migrating IT services to another data centre, a chapter on transition and transformation in the technical specifications and a separate price table. On the merits, what mattered was not the length of the migration but its complexity, risk and business impact — a point D. itself had stressed in the market consultation — and D. did not show an intent to restrict competition artificially; the termination right after six years, meant for major strategic changes, did not contradict the chosen term. The second plea targeted the criterion ‘Services offered and their organisation’ and the sub-criterion ‘CO2 neutrality’. Read with the technical specifications, which required CVs for five key roles (Service Delivery Manager, Incident/Problem Manager, Security Manager, Change Manager and Lead Project Manager), a description of the delivering organisation and a service catalogue beyond the minimum, the criterion assessed the tender; Article 81(2)(3)(b) allows staff qualifications to count where they significantly affect performance. The CO2 sub-criterion concerned support and reporting within this contract; no tenderer offered a binding commitment and all three scored 1 out of 5. D.’s higher score in the withdrawn first award was irrelevant, since a withdrawn decision is deemed never to have existed. The application was dismissed; D. was ordered to pay the court fee of EUR 200, a EUR 26 contribution and a EUR 770 procedural indemnity to Fluvius. First auditor Ines Martens concurred.

Why does this matter?

Article 135 limits utilities-sector contracts to eight years ‘as a general rule’, and this judgment shows how much room those words leave: a longer term is possible if justified in advance, by the competent body, with objective, contract-specific reasons — here the risks of a data centre migration and alignment with server renewal, backed by an NPV comparison. A later, fuller explanation in the award report is then not an after-the-fact justification, and a challenger must show an artificial restriction of competition or disproportionality. The judgment also shows that a criterion which seems to assess the tenderer is read together with the technical specifications: if those require specific key staff, organisation and sustainability measures for this contract, the tender is being assessed. Finally, scores from a withdrawn award carry no weight.

The lesson

Contracting authorities in the utilities sectors: record the reasons for exceeding eight years before publication, in a document approved by the competent body, and make them concrete — risks, costs, cycles. Tie qualitative criteria explicitly to the key profiles, organisation and commitments required for this contract. Tenderers: challenge a term or criterion you consider flawed during the procedure, not after losing; and do not rely on scores from a withdrawn decision.

Ask yourself

As an authority: is the justification for a term beyond eight years approved before publication, and is it specific rather than generic? Do your qualitative criteria refer to concrete parts of the technical specifications? As a tenderer: did you raise doubts about the term or criteria in time? Does your tender describe key staff, organisation and sustainability measures specifically for this contract?

About this database

The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →