Rejection French-speaking chamber

B.E. Fin calls itself a ‘public-law limited company’ and the notice points to the Council of State — yet the Council has no jurisdiction over Jolimont’s RenoWatt contract

Ruling nr. 267360 · 7 July 2026 · VIe vakantiekamer

The Council of State declines jurisdiction over the extreme-urgency suspension request brought by a consortium led by Louis De Waele Construction against the rejection of its bid for a RenoWatt energy performance contract for buildings of the Jolimont group, because the contracting authority B.E. Fin is prima facie not an administrative authority: its creation or recognition by the public authorities has not been shown, and an award decision is not a decision binding on third parties.

What happened?

Four companies — Louis De Waele Construction, Imtech Belgium, Montois Architects and Bureau d’expert Ph. Deplasse & Associés — bid jointly for a RenoWatt-subsidised services contract: an energy performance contract for the energy renovation of several buildings of the Jolimont group. The contracting authority was B.E. Fin, a subsidiary of Wallonie Entreprendre, which described itself in the specifications as contracting authority ‘under a delegated mission for the Walloon Region in the framework of the RenoWatt project’. The contract was awarded through a competitive procedure with negotiation. The notice was published in the Official Journal of the EU on 4 March 2025. The consortium was selected on 30 June 2025, submitted a bid on 8 October 2025, negotiated on 7 November 2025, filed a first BAFO on 23 January 2026 and a second on 16 March 2026, following a new BAFO request of 5 March 2026. On 27 May 2026 B.E. Fin’s board declared its bid substantially irregular and — as the consortium inferred from a part of the decision not notified to it — awarded the contract to another bidder, whose identity it did not know. The decision was notified on 2 June 2026. On 16 June 2026 the consortium sought suspension under the extreme-urgency procedure and annulment. It was itself unsure of the Council’s jurisdiction: ‘to be safe’, it had also summoned B.E. Fin in summary proceedings before the Liège enterprise court. It argued that under its articles of association B.E. Fin is a ‘public-law limited company’ and a ‘specialised company’ of the Walloon Region within the meaning of Article 24 of the Decree of 19 October 2022, without a budget of its own, and referred to a ministerial answer to a written question of 12 February 2024 and to earlier judgments, including one on SOWAER. B.E. Fin itself doubted in its note whether it was an administrative authority, but argued at the hearing that it was one because it acted in the name and on behalf of the Walloon Region. The Council noted that Article 24 of the Law of 17 June 2013 allocates jurisdiction: the Council of State where the contracting authority is an authority within the meaning of Article 14(1) of the Council of State Act, otherwise the ordinary courts — precisely to prevent forum shopping. B.E. Fin was incorporated on 21 February 1979; its articles call it a specialised company, allow dissolution only by decree and provide that half of the eight directors are appointed on the proposal of the Walloon Government. But B.E. Fin produced no government decree underpinning the delegated RenoWatt mission, nor the decree that would justify the 2018 amendment of its articles describing it as a ‘specialised company’; the parliamentary answer rather suggested a ‘specialised subsidiary’ within the meaning of Article 6 of the decree. Its creation or recognition by the public authorities was therefore not established. Moreover, according to the Court of Cassation, a private-law legal person, even one created and controlled by public authorities, is an administrative authority only if it can and does take unilateral decisions binding on third parties. According to the Council’s case law, a decision to award a contract to one bidder rather than another creates no obligations for third parties. The fact that the e-Procurement notice named the Council of State as review body was irrelevant: the rules on jurisdiction are a matter of public policy. The Council declined jurisdiction and dismissed the request. The bids, the negotiation minutes with the consortium and with the other bidders Luminus Solutions and Reno.Energy, and the analysis of the consortium’s bid remained confidential; costs were reserved.

Why does this matter?

In extreme-urgency proceedings an unsuccessful bidder has fifteen days. Knocking on the wrong court’s door loses valuable time — or more. This judgment shows that the question ‘Council of State or enterprise court?’ is not always obvious given the growing number of public and semi-public companies awarding contracts on behalf of a region. Labels in the articles of association such as ‘public-law company’ or ‘specialised company’ are not enough; the creation or recognition must follow from a decree or government order that is in the file. Even then, the decisive test is the Court of Cassation’s: can the legal person take unilateral decisions binding on third parties? According to the Council’s settled case law, an award decision does not. Nor does naming the Council of State as review body in the notice offer any support. The consortium had wisely protected itself with a parallel summons before the Liège enterprise court; without that precaution the challenge might well have been lost. The judgment says nothing about whether the rejection of the bid was justified.

The lesson

For bidders: when the contracting authority has a hybrid status — a subsidiary of a regional investment company, a company with delegated missions, an inter-municipal body in private-law form — do not rely blindly on the review body named in the notice. If in doubt, parallel summary proceedings before the ordinary courts, within the same deadline, are the safest course. For contracting authorities with such a status: make sure the notice names the correct review body and that you can produce the legal basis of your mission (decree, government order, delegation). Uncertainty on that point leads to duplicate proceedings and extra costs for everyone.

Ask yourself

As a bidder: do you know whether the contracting authority is an administrative authority within the meaning of Article 14(1) of the Council of State Act, or a private-law entity that can only be challenged before the ordinary courts? Does your assessment rest on more than the review body named in the notice or a label in the articles of association? If in doubt, have you also brought summary proceedings before the ordinary courts within the same deadline? As a contracting authority with a hybrid status: can you produce the decree or government order underpinning your creation, recognition or delegated mission? Does your notice name the review body that actually has jurisdiction, and has that been legally checked?

About this database

The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →