Rejection French-speaking chamber

Place Douffet in Saint-Georges-sur-Meuse: a subcontractor’s quote plus 10% overhead is no price justification — not even when the concrete comes from the winning bidder itself

Ruling nr. 267421 · 17 July 2026 · VIe vakantiekamer, zetelend in kort geding

The municipality of Saint-Georges-sur-Meuse rejected the cheapest tender, from Cop et Portier (EUR 419,844.15 excluding VAT), for the redevelopment of the Place Douffet on account of abnormally low unit prices and awarded the lot to Loiseau (EUR 459,215.15 excluding VAT); the Council of State dismissed the application for suspension under extreme urgency, because an error in calculating the 15% threshold did not prejudice the applicant and because a price justification consisting mainly of a subcontractor’s quote plus 10% overhead, without output rates or resources deployed, could rightly be regarded as insufficient.

What happened?

The municipality of Saint-Georges-sur-Meuse put out a works contract entitled ‘PCDR – Aménagements de la place Douffet (lot 1) et construction d’une halle couverte (lot 2)’: the redevelopment of the Place Douffet and the construction of a covered hall, under specifications no. 2024-449 and with price as the sole award criterion. Lot 1 was estimated at EUR 522,780.18 excluding VAT. Thirteen tenders were received. Entreprises Cop et Portier SA was the cheapest at EUR 419,844.15 excluding VAT. The tender evaluation report calculated an average of EUR 512,216.86 and an 85% threshold of EUR 435,384.33, below which Cop et Portier’s tender fell. On 8 April 2026 the municipality asked both Cop et Portier and Loiseau SRL to justify, within twelve calendar days, their unit prices for items 39 to 43, stating that justifications had to be concrete, quantified and supported by documents, and that prices for subcontracted items had to be justified in the same way. On 13 April 2026 Cop et Portier replied with its subcontractor’s price quote, increased by 10% overheads, and a price justification drawn up by that subcontractor. The same day, the municipality wrote that this did not, ‘as it stands’, suffice and asked, within five working days, for technical data sheets and supplier quotes for the visqueen membrane, the concrete, the foam, the water-repellent, the mesh reinforcement, the bar chairs and concrete strips, and the product used to expose the aggregate. Cop et Portier provided those documents on 20 April 2026; Loiseau had submitted its justification on 16 April 2026. The report of 4 May 2026 accepted Loiseau’s justification — a structured breakdown into cost price, overheads and profit margin, with quantities, unit prices and resources deployed, and an economic explanation based on its proximity to the site, its control over supplies and its in-house concrete production — but rejected Cop et Portier’s as too summary: no analysis of the subcontractor’s price build-up, no output rates, no human and material resources, no site conditions, and technical sheets with no direct link to the economic justification. By a decision of 12 May 2026, notified on 5 June 2026, the municipal executive declared Cop et Portier’s tender void and awarded lot 1 to Loiseau for EUR 459,215.15 excluding VAT (EUR 555,650.33 including VAT). On 19 June 2026 Cop et Portier sought suspension under extreme urgency, without an annulment action. It pointed out that with thirteen tenders the municipality should have excluded the highest quarter (four tenders), so that the threshold was EUR 423,067.58, and its tender was only EUR 3,223.43, or about 0.77%, below it. The Council acknowledged that calculation error — the municipality did not dispute it — but held that Cop et Portier’s tender remained below the correct threshold as well, so that it had not shown how the error could prejudice it. Moreover, the report showed that the rejection was based on the unit prices of specific items, not on the total price. The method for identifying non-negligible items (2% of the tender amount, supplemented by items with highly variable quantities or items linked to them) was not disputed; items 39, 42 and 43 exceeded that 2%, and items 40 and 41, which fell below it, appeared prima facie technically inseparable from the other three, as they all concerned the cement-concrete paving of the square. On the substance, the Council found that Cop et Portier, although questioned twice, had provided only a very brief cost breakdown, without explaining, beyond global labour rates, which staff and equipment it would use to achieve the expected output. It is not for the contracting authority to set out the expected output; it need only check that the output proposed is reasonable and the prices economically coherent. The report to the King on the royal decree of 18 April 2017 states it in so many words: a bidder cannot simply refer to a subcontractor’s price plus a profit margin. The concrete argument failed too. Cop et Portier sourced its concrete from Loiseau itself — according to Cop et Portier at EUR 127 per m³, plus 10% — but concrete is only one component of item 39, and Loiseau’s unit price for that item was nearly 50% higher than Cop et Portier’s. There was therefore no unequal treatment: the justifications differed substantially in detail. Finally, the Council found that not disclosing Loiseau’s justification to Cop et Portier was consistent with article 13, § 2, of the law of 17 June 2016, especially since Cop et Portier itself requested confidentiality for its tender. The application was dismissed, immediate enforcement of the judgment was ordered and the confidentiality of both parties’ documents was maintained. As there was no annulment action, costs were settled at once: Cop et Portier pays the roll fee of EUR 200, the contribution of EUR 26 and a procedural indemnity of EUR 770 to the municipality.

Why does this matter?

The judgment brings together three lessons on price examination that often get mixed up in practice. The first concerns calculation errors: a wrongly calculated 15% threshold is only a usable plea if the bidder shows it was prejudiced by it. If the tender also falls below the correct threshold — here by barely 0.77% — the finding that the tender lies ‘below the threshold’ remains correct and the error changes nothing. The second lesson concerns what a justification must contain. The Council repeats that a mere cost breakdown is not enough if it does not allow the authority to check whether the unit prices permit proper performance, and that passing on a subcontractor’s quote plus a margin — expressly named in the report to the King — is not a justification. Technical data sheets and BENOR certificates show what is supplied, not why the price is right. The authority’s duty of care is weighed against the bidder’s duty to answer in detail: a bidder that gets two chances and does not use them cannot blame the authority for not asking a third time. The third lesson concerns equal treatment. That the winner could base its justification on its own concrete production, while the loser bought the same concrete from that winner, looks at first sight like a double standard. But concrete is only one component of the item, and the winner charged a unit price nearly 50% higher for it. Equal treatment does not mean that justifications of different quality must be assessed alike. Finally, the judgment confirms that the authority need not disclose the winner’s justification: brief but not laconic reasoning suffices to show that it examined it carefully.

The lesson

If you are asked as a bidder to justify your prices, answer as if you had to explain the calculation to a sceptical site manager: which crew, how many hours, which equipment, what output per day or per m², which material prices and which margin. If your price relies on a subcontractor or supplier, have them break down their own price in the same way — a quote plus 10% overhead is not enough, and the report to the King says so explicitly. Technical data sheets and certificates are useful as annexes, not as justification. Treat a second request as a real second chance: if the authority asks for more, add figures, not just the documents requested. And think before invoking a calculation error: if you are below the correct threshold too, you gain nothing by it. If you are a contracting authority, explain in the evaluation report how you identified the non-negligible items, justify why items below your threshold still count, and give reasons, bidder by bidder, for accepting or rejecting a justification. Check your threshold calculation — here the error cost the municipality nothing, but that was luck. Finally, keep the winner’s justification confidential, but make sure your reasoning shows that you really examined it.

Ask yourself

Does your price justification contain output rates, crew composition, equipment and site conditions, or only a cost breakdown and a pile of technical sheets? If you rely on a subcontractor: have you also broken down its price, or merely passed on its quote plus your overhead? Did you use a second request for justification to add real figures? Have you checked whether you would also fall below a correctly calculated threshold before pleading a calculation error? And as a contracting authority: does your report make clear which items are non-negligible and why, do you assess each justification on its own merits, and does your reasoning on the winner remain brief without becoming laconic?

About this database

The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →