3,800 euros for a heat-network feasibility study: Council of State accepts SPI’s rejection of SML Ingénieurs Conseils’ bid for an abnormally low price
The Liège development agency SPI was entitled to declare null the bid of SML Ingénieurs Conseils for the design contract for the Wérihet business park, because its justification of 3,800 euros — 76 hours at 43 euros plus 15 percent — for the feasibility study of a heat network was unconvincing, the synergies invoked with another tranche were not guaranteed, and that single item, the only one assessed on price, was anything but negligible.
What happened?
On 27 February 2026 SPI, the development agency of the province of Liège, decided to launch an open procedure for a services contract covering the design and supervision of the infrastructure works for the ‘Wérihet’ business park in Liège. The works themselves were estimated at 11,500,000 euros incl. VAT and the design contract at 538,750 euros excl. VAT. Specification no. 2025-2414 comprised three firm tranches (business-park infrastructure, heat-network feasibility, water infrastructure) and two conditional ones (infrastructure on the regional road and heat-network infrastructure). Fees were fixed for all tranches except tranche 2, the heat-network feasibility study, for which bidders had to quote a global lump sum. The price criterion (20 of 100 points) therefore turned solely on that one amount; the rest of the score came from methodology for the infrastructure (60), methodology for the heat network (10) and quality of the bid (10). Seven bids were received. On 24 April 2026 SPI asked four bidders — SML Ingénieurs Conseils, ARCADIS Belgium, SOTREZ-NIZET and the temporary association GREISCH-AUPa — to confirm or correct their price for tranche 2 and, if confirmed, to justify it. SML confirmed: its study would take 76 hours, two full working weeks of one engineer, at an actual cost of 43 euros per hour according to a calculation by the social secretariat UCM; 3,268 euros plus 15 percent overheads and profit gave 3,758.20 euros, rounded to 3,800 euros excl. VAT. It pointed to its in-house resources, databases from earlier similar studies and synergies with tranche 1. A first award decision of 26 June 2026 was challenged by SML, but SPI withdrew it on 29 July 2026 and replaced it the same day with a new decision based on an amended bid-review report of 23 July 2026. That report declared the bids of SML and ARCADIS Belgium null for an abnormal price for tranche 2 and awarded the contract to GREISCH-AUPa (75 points, of which 11 out of 20 for price), ahead of SOTREZ-NIZET (68 points, 20 out of 20 for price) and BICE-GESPLAN (55 points, 2 out of 20 for price). SML’s first urgency application was declared inadmissible for lack of interest by judgment no. 267.463 of 7 August 2026. On 13 August 2026 SML again sought suspension under extreme urgency, this time of the decision of 29 July 2026. The president of the VIth vacation chamber declared of its own motion that the action against the bid-review report was inadmissible (a preparatory act) and rejected both pleas. On equal treatment: SML had no interest in complaining that SPI had not questioned BICE-GESPLAN about its high price, since that bidder did not win the contract; and SPI had explained concretely why SML’s justification — with only 4 hours for the analysis of energy needs, 8 hours for financial modelling over fifteen years, 2 hours for comparing the scenarios and 2 hours for drafting all deliverables — was insufficient, even though it accepted comparable optimisation arguments from SOTREZ-NIZET and GREISCH-AUPa; it was also entitled to regard the hour volumes of 76, 100 and 168 hours as not comparable. On the price examination: the burden of proof lies with the bidder questioned, and article 36, § 3, does not require the authority to show that performance at that price is absolutely impossible; if the justification does not dispel the appearance of abnormality, the bid must be rejected. The hourly rate of 43 euros only described an internal salary cost, not how specialised technical, financial and legal profiles would be deployed within tight deadlines. SPI was entitled to reject the synergies with tranche 1 because the specification treats the tranches as autonomous assignments and expressly does not guarantee that they will be performed concurrently. The reference to the FABI scales was not an additional requirement but a further indication that the rate had not been justified. On negligibility: SML set its own 3,800 euros against roughly 303,000 euros in fees (1.25 percent) and against the estimate of 538,750 euros (0.7 percent), but the Council calculated with the average of the bids (31,722 euros excl. VAT, or 25,845 euros without the highest and lowest), representing 10.47 or 8.5 percent of the value of the tranches — and it is moreover the only item assessed on price and a prerequisite for conditional tranche 5. Since the authority’s power is then a bound one, the argument that declaring the bid null was disproportionate also failed. The application was rejected; costs were reserved.
Why does this matter?
This is an instructive judgment on price justification, and this time it goes the authority’s way. Three points stand out. First: anyone justifying an abnormally low price with an estimate of hours must be able to defend that estimate task by task against the scope of what the specification requires; a global hourly rate from a salary simulation says nothing about the real cost of a specialised assignment. Second: synergies with another tranche of the same contract are a shaky argument when the specification sets the tranches up as self-standing assignments and does not guarantee that they will run together — the authority must be able to assess each tranche on its own. Third, and sharpest: whether an item is ‘negligible’ is not measured against the bidder’s own low price, but against the average of the bids and the weight of the item in the contract. A bidder therefore cannot set its own price so low that it escapes the price check for precisely that reason. The judgment also confirms useful limits on what an authority must do: it need not prescribe a ‘normal’ number of hours, need not question the bidder again, and may compare competitors’ justifications without having to disclose their confidential hours. For anyone bidding for design and engineering contracts this is a clear warning: pricing aggressively on the only item assessed on price is a strategy that only works if you can also substantiate it task by task.
The lesson
For bidders: if you are asked to justify a price, treat that request as the most important text in your bid. Link every hour to a specific task in the specification, with the profiles you will deploy; a salary simulation from a social secretariat is not enough to show economic viability. Do not base your price on synergies with another tranche if the specification does not guarantee that those tranches will be performed together. Attach every document supporting your price to your justification straight away: documents you only file with the Council of State do not count. And do not count on a low item being ‘negligible’ because your own amount is small: the Council looks at the average of the bids. For authorities: this judgment shows how a rejection for abnormal price holds up — with reasoning that tests the justification task by task against the specification, explains why similar arguments convinced in the case of competitors but not here, and substantiates the non-negligible character of the item both financially and technically. Making an item the only one assessed on price, moreover, makes that item important by definition.
Ask yourself
As a bidder: can you show, for every task described in the specification, how many hours you will spend on it, with which profile, and why that is enough? Does your price justification rely on synergies with another tranche or contract, and does the specification actually guarantee that they will be performed together? Does your hourly rate reflect the full economic cost — including specialised profiles, overheads and tight deadlines — or only an internal salary cost? Have you attached all supporting documents to your price justification, rather than producing them later in the proceedings? As an authority: do you give concrete, item-by-item reasons for rejecting a bid for abnormal price, and do you explain why comparable arguments from other bidders were accepted? Have you substantiated the non-negligible character of the item by reference to the average of the bids and the role of the item in the contract?
About this database
The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →