Rejection Dutch-speaking chamber

International Press Centre restaurant: silence on minimum requirements does not make a tender irregular, and the State did not have to publish the incumbent’s staff list

Ruling nr. 267879 · 30 September 2026 · XIVe kamer

C., the incumbent operator of the restaurant and catering in the Résidence Palace, challenged the award of the new five-year concession to H. on the grounds that H.’s tender did not expressly confirm the minimum requirements, that the concession document was silent on a possible transfer of staff under collective agreement no. 32bis, and that the quality scores were too vaguely reasoned, but the Council of State found none of the pleas serious and dismissed the application for suspension under extreme urgency.

What happened?

The Belgian State, through the Federal Public Service Chancellery of the Prime Minister, put out a services concession for the exclusive operation of the publicly accessible restaurant in block C of the Résidence Palace – International Press Centre (IPC) on the Rue de la Loi and of event catering in the premises under concession, for five years. The value was estimated at EUR 1,300,000 a year or EUR 6,500,000 in total, below the European threshold, so the concession was only published in the Belgian procurement bulletin. The concessionaire pays a fee equal to a percentage of net turnover — 19% up to EUR 1,000,000, falling per band to 8% above EUR 1,700,000 — with a guaranteed minimum of EUR 90,000 a year. The award followed negotiation, on 100 points: quality of the concept note (50, including vision 10 and fit-out proposals 7), percentages offered above the minimum (20), quality of the culinary offer based on a tasting session (20) and a discount for federal institutions and press organisations (10). On the publicprocurement.be forum the State answered on 18 May 2026 that at the previous changeover one staff member, the current maître d’hôtel, had moved to the new operator, but by private arrangement. On 26 May 2026 two candidates submitted tenders: C., the incumbent concessionaire, and H. After a tasting session on 10 June 2026, two interim tenders and a BAFO, both tenders were found regular and the Prime Minister awarded the concession to H. C. was informed on 20 August 2026 and again on 28 August 2026, by a replacement letter stating the remedies. On 3 September 2026 it applied for suspension under extreme urgency on three pleas. First plea: H.’s tender did not expressly confirm the minimum requirements ‘catering possible outside office hours’, ‘no extra charge for private hire’ and the EUR 90,000 minimum fee; according to C., ‘silence gives consent’ does not apply in procurement law. The Council disagreed. Neither the concession document nor article 30 of the royal decree of 25 June 2017 requires bidders to confirm those requirements explicitly, and under the document submitting a tender amounts to accepting all its terms. For catering outside office hours, several elements of the tender, including a table with separate rates for evening and weekend work, showed that H. had taken it into account. The ban on an extra charge is a negative obligation, for which it suffices that the tender mentions no such charge — the same yardstick used for C.’s own tender. And the minimum fee is a pre-set concession condition; a bidder offering higher percentages within that system without reservation also accepts the minimum. Second plea: the concession changeover would be a transfer of undertaking under collective agreement no. 32bis, and the document said nothing about the employees to be taken over or their terms. The Council held that the obligations under that agreement fall primarily on the transferor and transferee, under the supervision of the labour court. Whether there is a transfer depends on an overall factual assessment (Spijkers case law), which the State could not foresee when drafting the document, given the wide freedom it left bidders. No general duty to proactively publish the incumbent’s staff list follows from the case law relied on. That C. itself, as incumbent, had made no comments and supplied no information during the procedure undermined its complaint. Moreover, H. had raised the question itself, the State had consulted the Federal Public Service Employment and informed the bidders, and H. had expressly confirmed in its BAFO that it allowed for a possible application of the agreement, despite that service’s view that it did not apply. The complaints based on the joint committee 302 sectoral rules and on the directive itself were inadmissible. Third plea: the reasoning of the quality scores. On ‘vision’ (9 against 8 out of 10), the State praised H.’s ‘Kaisin’ and ‘K-markt’ concepts without disclosing their content; the Council found this acceptable, since the duty to state reasons does not require ‘reasons for the reasons’ and the information was commercially sensitive, while the reasoning also cited other strengths, such as an all-in price guarantee for event catering. On ‘fit-out proposals’ (6.5 against 5.5 out of 7), the State was entitled, for the ‘removable shelter elements’ on the roof terrace, to examine whether they were genuinely easy to move, even daily, since the document itself asked for easy set-up and dismantling. On ‘culinary offer’ (16.82 against 15.95 out of 20), each committee member had scored the dishes individually and the arithmetic mean had, after discussion, been endorsed by all members; according to the Council this is compatible with the announced assessment ‘by consensus’, and taste, presentation, texture and overall quality are not hidden sub-criteria but assessment elements inherent in a tasting session. No plea was serious; the application was dismissed. C. bears the 200-euro roll fee, the 26-euro contribution and a 770-euro procedural indemnity payable to the State; H. bears its 150-euro intervention fee.

Why does this matter?

This judgment answers three questions that regularly arise in concessions and service contracts with an incumbent operator. First: must a tender expressly confirm every minimum requirement? No, unless the procurement documents ask for it. A tender’s silence is not a reservation, particularly where the document provides that submission amounts to acceptance, and the authority may infer from the tender as a whole that a requirement is met. For negative obligations, such as a ban on an extra charge, it is enough that the tender does not contradict it. Second: must the authority address a possible transfer of undertaking in the specifications and publish the incumbent’s staff list? According to the Council, not as a general duty. Whether collective agreement no. 32bis applies depends on facts that only become clear during performance, and the obligations rest on the undertakings concerned. An incumbent that supplies no information itself and does not challenge the document is in a weak position when it later raises this as a defect. Third: how far does the duty to state reasons go for qualitative criteria? The Council accepts that commercially sensitive concepts need not be disclosed in detail, that the reasoning is assessed as a whole rather than sentence by isolated sentence, and that an average of individual scores, after discussion, can be a consensus. An authority may also use assessment elements that logically belong to a criterion without these becoming new sub-criteria.

The lesson

For bidders: do not expect a competitor to be excluded because its tender does not literally repeat every minimum requirement; look for a genuine reservation or contradiction. If you are the incumbent and fear the changeover will lead to a transfer of staff, ask questions during the procedure, supply the information yourself or challenge the document in time — complaining afterwards about its silence hardly works. Whoever attacks the reasoning of quality scores must criticise the reasoning as a whole and provide concrete indications of factual errors; setting your own view against the committee’s is not enough. For authorities: provide in the document that submission implies acceptance of all its terms, explain the strengths and weaknesses of each tender per criterion, and document how a consensus was reached. Where a transfer of undertaking is possible, it pays, as here, to answer questions, consult the competent federal service and inform all bidders equally.

Ask yourself

Do the specifications or concession document expressly require you to confirm each minimum requirement, or does submitting your tender count as acceptance? Does your tender contain any reservation or contradiction with a minimum requirement? As incumbent: did you raise the question of a possible transfer of staff during the procedure or supply the necessary information yourself? Have you priced in a possible application of collective agreement no. 32bis? When attacking quality scores, can you point to concrete factual errors, or are you merely setting your own judgement against the committee’s? And as an authority: can you show that the final score is endorsed by all committee members, and do your assessment elements stay within the scope of the published criteria?

About this database

The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →