Rejection Dutch-speaking chamber

Ghent was entitled to reject the Spellewerkstraat bid over a single soil-removal item priced 57% below average

Ruling nr. 267881 · 30 September 2026 · XIVe kamer

V. submitted the third-lowest bid for the redevelopment of the Spellewerkstraat cluster in Ghent, but saw it rejected because its unit price for item 99 (removal and processing of soil) was 57% below average and its justification — 30% of the soil would be reused — left out the cost of temporary storage off site; the Council of State found the 1% threshold for non-negligible items reasonable and equally applied, read the specifications as the city did, and dismissed the application for suspension under extreme urgency.

What happened?

The City of Ghent, together with the inter-municipal association Farys, put out a public works contract for the complete redevelopment of the sewers and road surface in the Spellewerkstraat, the Satijnstraat and the Kantstraat, including the junctions with the Gérard Willemotlaan, the Flanelstraat, the Adriaan Pietersstraat and the Brugsesteenweg (specifications TDW/2026/006 – ID5903). The city acted as contracting authority, chose an open procedure and used price as the sole award criterion. Six bidders submitted a tender by 26 May 2026. After review, the ranking was: TM N.-A. (EUR 3,756,336.33), P. (EUR 3,767,728.56), V. (EUR 3,865,511.48), O. (EUR 3,891,298.94), A. (EUR 3,944,558.96) and W. (EUR 4,819,009.18), all including VAT. No total price was apparently abnormally low, but the city also examined unit prices. It regarded an item as significant where the average total price of all tenders for that item exceeded 1% of the average total tender price, and a unit price as apparently abnormally low at 30% below average (abnormally high at 50% above). Twenty items, including item 99, and a group of items on protecting valuable trees and greenery against groundwater lowering met that threshold. In V.’s tender, the unit price for item 99 — removal and processing of 1,088 m³ of excavated soil — was 57% below average. On 5 June 2026 the city asked for a price justification. V. replied that 30% of the soil would be reused to backfill and bed the sewer pipes, so it priced the item on 761.60 m³ of soil to be removed; it had included the extra costs of reuse, as article 2-7.1.1 of the specifications requires, in the backfill and bedding items. The city did not accept this. The specifications impose phasing: the next phase may only start once the base layer of the previous phase is in place, so soil from the road structure cannot go straight into the sewer trench of the next phase and must be stored temporarily, outside the site boundaries. Transport to that storage location, the storage itself and preparing the soil for reuse were not in the justification. The three lowest tenders were all rejected for containing at least one unacceptable unit price, and on 20 August 2026 the board of mayor and aldermen awarded the contract to O. as the lowest regular bidder. V. applied on 3 September 2026 for suspension under extreme urgency. O. argued that the applicant had no interest, since its tender was irregular in any event and other regular tenders remained. The Council rejected that objection: an interest in having another chance at the contract suffices, and the objection anticipated a fresh assessment of the tenders. On the merits, however, V. got nowhere. Neither the law nor the royal decree lays down a criterion for deciding which items are negligible; that must be assessed contract by contract. The 1% threshold is an objective, mathematical criterion, calculated on the average of all tenders and therefore the same for everyone. The argument that item 99 exceeded the threshold by barely 0.10 percentage points (1.1%) did not convince: a threshold is a threshold, and the specifications also showed the qualitative importance of the earthworks. The confidential price analysis table showed that the thresholds had actually been applied, and applied equally. On substance, the Council read article 2-7.1.1 as the city did: it concerns the extra costs of actually using reusable soil (harder compaction, dewatering, lower productivity), not the costs of first making the soil available through temporary storage off site, which belong under item 99. The reference to other bidders’ accepted justifications and the complaint that the city should have questioned it again also failed: a second request is an option, not a duty, where the justification suffices to reach a view. The application was dismissed. V. bears the 200-euro roll fee, the 26-euro contribution and a 770-euro procedural indemnity payable to the city; O. bears its 150-euro intervention fee.

Why does this matter?

This judgment shows how a single item can sink a tender worth almost EUR 3.9 million. V. did not lose on its total price, which was normal, but on a soil-removal item that only just crossed the significance threshold. Three lessons stand out. First, the Council gives contracting authorities wide latitude to decide what a non-negligible item is: a threshold of 1% of the average total price, applied in advance and equally to all, is accepted, and exceeding it by 0.10 percentage points is still exceeding it. Crucially, the threshold is calculated on the average of all tenders, not on the item’s share in the bidder’s own tender — a share that is unreliable precisely when the bidder’s own price is abnormally low. Second, a price justification is assessed against the specifications as a whole: the phasing and the obligation to store soil off site meant that, according to the Council, the costs V. had placed elsewhere belonged under item 99. A bidder who shifts costs between items must be able to justify that from the specifications themselves. Third, the judgment confirms that the burden of proof lies with the bidder and that there is no guaranteed second chance: whoever receives a price query must answer fully and concretely straight away. That the city rejected the three lowest tenders shows it took the price review seriously, which the Council took into account through the confidential price analysis table.

The lesson

If, as a bidder, you receive a request for price justification, treat it as the moment your tender survives or falls. Justify every cost component of the queried item — here transport to and storage in a temporary storage location and preparing the soil — and, if you priced costs under another item, show by reference to the specifications where each cost sits. Read the phasing and execution clauses too: they determine which costs the authority expects in an item. Do not count on being asked again, and do not expect the Council to find a 1% threshold disproportionate because you are only just above it. As a contracting authority, this judgment shows what works: set objective thresholds in advance (significance, apparently abnormally low or high), apply them equally to all bidders, document this in a price analysis table and explain concretely in the evaluation report why a justification falls short, with reference to the specification clauses.

Ask yourself

Do you know how the authority decides which items are non-negligible, and have you checked which of your unit prices might sit more than 30% below the expected average? If you price costs of one item in another, can you show, specifications in hand, that this is allowed and exactly where those costs are? Does your price account for the phasing and for where soil must be stored temporarily? Is your price justification complete enough to be assessed without a further request? And as an authority: are your price-review thresholds fixed in advance, applied equally to all bidders and verifiable in the file, and does your reasoning refer to the specific specification clauses?

About this database

The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →