A temporary consortium cannot litigate: Artes loses its extreme-urgency application over a renovation lot worth more than 30 million euros at the Grand Bazar in Verviers on the name in the application
The temporary consortium Artes TWT – Artes Roegiers came in about 286,000 euros above the successful tenderer for lot 1 of the Grand Bazar renovation in Verviers and applied for suspension of the award, but the Council of State declared the application inadmissible because the consortium, which has no legal personality, was named as the sole applicant and the Council refused to read its two members into the application after the fact.
What happened?
The city of Verviers wants to convert the Grand Bazar into an administrative centre. On 10 February 2026 it published in the Belgian tender bulletin and the Official Journal of the EU a works contract under the open procedure, ‘Réhabilitation globale et rénovation énergétique du Grand Bazar en Cité administrative’, in two lots: lot 1 ‘shell, building services and finishing’ (also described in the specifications as demolition, shell, external envelope, building services and high-voltage substation) and lot 2 ‘lifts’. On 20 May 2026, the deadline set by a corrigendum of 7 April, six tenders came in for lot 1, all above 30 million euros including VAT: the temporary consortium Artes TWT – Artes Roegiers at 31,143,322.13 euros, the temporary consortium Duchêne – Gilles Moury at 30,857,542.82 euros, BPC Group at 31,905,446.94 euros, Franki – J. Wust at 32,231,217.19 euros, Galère – Denys at 32,790,267.62 euros and Bernard Construction – Serbi – Batitec at 34,019,595.53 euros. On 20 August 2026 the municipal executive awarded lot 1 to Duchêne – Gilles Moury, on the basis of the designer’s evaluation report, which it made an integral part of its decision. Artes received the reasoned decision on 21 August by e-mail and registered letter. On 7 September 2026 ‘the temporary consortium Artes TWT SA – Artes Roegiers NV’ applied for suspension under extreme urgency. The Council went no further than admissibility. The city argued that since the Code of Companies and Associations a temporary consortium is a partnership and therefore has no legal personality (Article 1:5(1) CCA). At the hearing Artes replied that the name in the application was merely a collective designation of its two members, which both appeared in that name, had filed their articles of association, were represented by the same lawyers and had both paid the court fee; the scheduling order also named both companies. It relied on judgments nos. 251.465 and 260.514, on Article 703(2) of the Judicial Code and on two decisions of its members to bring proceedings. Chamber president David De Roy, sitting alone, rejected all of this. Whoever tenders as a temporary consortium can only go to the Council through the members themselves, and they must act together unless the consortium agreement contains a representation clause. There was none here, as Artes itself had stated in reply to an investigative measure by the auditor. The application named the temporary consortium, with its registered office in Andenne and its company number, as the sole applicant and consistently referred to ‘the applicant’ in the singular. Reading the two members as applicants would mean the Council substituting two new parties for the only one named in the application, which it cannot do. Nor did Artes claim it was a clerical error that could still be corrected. The name, the articles and the company number at most made it easy to identify the members, but did not prove that they had themselves acted as applicants; for that the application had to state their names and all required details, and their registered offices were missing. That followed from Article 4(1), first paragraph, 2°, of the Royal Decree of 19 November 2024 on interim proceedings, which also applies to extreme urgency. The double court fee and the scheduling order proved nothing: the registry had asked for that payment, and neither document prejudges admissibility. The two judgments cited had not been handed down in a sufficiently comparable procedural context. Article 703(2) of the Judicial Code did not apply, because the Royal Decree of 19 November 2024 itself governs the identification of the applicant, and that provision is moreover designed for writs of summons concerning the members’ common rights, not for objective proceedings before the Council. And the two decisions to bring proceedings showed precisely that nothing had prevented the members from acting as applicants themselves. That the two companies could still bring an annulment action until 20 October 2026, and would do so, was irrelevant to this application. On 2 October 2026 the Council dismissed the application as inadmissible, in line with the concurring opinion of auditor Marie Lambert de Rouvroit, and ordered immediate enforcement. The confidential documents remained confidential. Artes had to bear the costs, including a procedural indemnity of 770 euros for the city. Because there was only one applicant, it was however refunded 200 euros in court fees paid in excess: the registry had asked for 426 euros instead of 226.
Why does this matter?
Temporary consortia are the rule rather than the exception in large construction contracts. This judgment shows how costly a formal error in the application can then be: an extreme-urgency application concerning a lot worth more than 30 million euros, with a difference of about 286,000 euros between the applicant and the successful tenderer, fails without the Council examining a single plea on the merits. The rule itself is not new: a temporary consortium is a partnership without legal personality and therefore cannot itself bring proceedings; all members must act together unless there is a representation clause. What the judgment adds is how strictly the Council applies that rule in interim proceedings. It refuses to read the application benevolently as a joint application by the members, even though their names appear in the consortium’s name, their articles are attached, both paid the court fee and the scheduling order names them. The application must designate the members themselves as applicants, with name and registered office, as Article 4 of the Royal Decree of 19 November 2024 requires. The attempt to invoke Article 703(2) of the Judicial Code fails because proceedings before the Council have their own rule and that provision is tailored to civil writs of summons. The judgment does leave a door ajar: a genuine clerical error might be corrected, but Artes did not argue that. In extreme-urgency proceedings there is in practice rarely time to repair such an error; here only the annulment action announced by the two companies remained.
The lesson
For bidders in a temporary consortium: have each member appear separately as an applicant, with full name, legal form, registered office and company number, and attach each member’s decision to bring proceedings. Use the consortium’s name at most as a description, never as the designation of the party, and write ‘the applicants’ in the plural. Decide when setting up the consortium whether it will include a representation clause for litigation, and know what it does and does not cover. Have your lawyer check this before filing: in extreme-urgency proceedings there is hardly any time left to repair the error. For contracting authorities: check in every application exactly who is acting as applicant. A temporary consortium litigating on its own, or one member acting without the others, is an admissibility defence that can make the entire debate on the merits unnecessary.
Ask yourself
As a bidder in a temporary consortium: are all members named separately as applicants in the application, with name and registered office? Does your agreement contain a representation clause for litigation, and if not, are all members acting together? Do you have a valid decision to bring proceedings for each member, and is it also used to designate them as applicants? As an authority: have you checked whether the applicant has legal personality and whether all members of the consortium have joined the proceedings?
About this database
The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →