Suspension Dutch-speaking chamber

A threshold that grows with your own bid: Leiedal sees the award of the infrastructure works on the Blauwpoort business park suspended because its screening of abnormal unit prices does not set the same bar for everyone

Ruling nr. 267926 · 5 October 2026 · XIVe kamer

On a road and sewerage contract worth over 9.5 million euros, the inter-municipal association Leiedal only queried a unit price as ‘apparently abnormally low’ if it was more than 30% below the average and the difference exceeded 1% of the tenderer’s own total bid — a threshold of 59,349.86 euros for the chosen tenderer — and the Council of State suspends the award because that method leaves non-negligible items out of view and applies a different bar to each tenderer.

What happened?

The inter-municipal service association Intercommunale Leiedal launched a public works contract entitled ‘Infrastructure works Blauwpoort business park’, in an open procedure. The works, conventional road and sewerage works, were estimated at 9,540,916.25 euros including VAT. Seven tenderers submitted a bid. On 28 August 2026 Leiedal awarded the contract to one of them. Another tenderer, S. NV (pseudonymised in the published judgment), applied on 15 September 2026 for suspension under extreme urgency. The Council examined only the second plea, which concerned the price examination. In the explanatory note to the award report, Leiedal had explained how it selected unit prices for closer examination. A price was ‘low’ if it was less than 0.7 times the average tender price calculated under article 36 of the Royal Decree of 18 April 2017, and if the difference from that average for the item exceeded 1% of the total amount of the tenderer’s own bid. The same cumulative 1% condition applied to ‘very low’ (0.2 times), ‘high’ (1.6 times) and ‘very high’ (4 times). To decide whether an item was significant, Leiedal also used a lower limit of 2,000 and an upper limit of 20,000 euros. S. NV worked out what that meant: for the chosen tenderer, an item was only queried if the difference from the average item price exceeded 59,349.86 euros excluding VAT. An item priced at 30,000 euros against an average of 85,000 euros — 65% lower — thus stayed under the radar, as did an item at 80,000 euros against an average of 137,000 euros, more than 41% lower. Moreover, the threshold differed from one tenderer to the next, because it depended on each one’s own bid. Leiedal replied that the rules impose no criteria for the price examination, that it was free to use a cumulative method, that a 42% deviation for a unit price is not unacceptable per se, and that the method had been applied to all tenderers in the same way. Chamber president Geert Debersaques accepted that a contracting authority has discretion to screen items and classify them as negligible or not, but only if the criteria are drawn up with care and guarantee equal treatment. Leiedal’s own written note showed that the 1% threshold also applied to items above 20,000 euros. At the hearing Leiedal seemed to want to read the method differently, but that new reading found no support in the administrative file, so the Council relied on what the note said. That showed, prima facie, that non-negligible items could fall outside the examination for abnormally low prices. And since the threshold was tied to each tenderer’s own bid amount, comparable price deviations led to a different selection for different tenderers — without objective and reasonable justification. That the method was applied identically to everyone made no difference: a rule applied without distinction can itself introduce inequality. The argument that 42% is not necessarily abnormal concerned the final assessment, not the prior selection. Reliance on an earlier judgment in another case did not help, because court decisions have no precedent effect in Belgian law. And the fact that Leiedal had taken the method over from another contracting authority that uses it regularly did not prove that it was lawful. The second plea was serious to that extent, in line with the opinion of first auditor Frederic Eggermont. The Council ordered the suspension of the award decision of 28 August 2026.

Why does this matter?

On large works contracts with hundreds of items, almost every contracting authority uses some kind of filter to decide which unit prices it asks bidders to justify. The Royal Decree of 18 April 2017 imposes no formula and even allows negligible items not to be queried. This judgment marks the limit of that freedom: a screening method is not a neutral calculation tool but a decision that must respect equal treatment. A threshold expressed as a percentage of the bidder’s own total looks objective, but it means that a more expensive bidder may deviate further on the same item before a question is asked. And it clashes with the authority’s own 20,000-euro limit for what is ‘significant’: an 80,000-euro item that is 41% below average is hard to call negligible. The judgment is also a lesson in litigation. The Council holds Leiedal to the explanation in its own written note, not to a new reading at the hearing that the file does not support. It recalls that earlier judgments are not precedents, and that a method does not become lawful because other authorities use it too. For Leiedal it is the second suspension in a short time in which prices take centre stage: in August 2026 the award of its bike-sharing concession had already been suspended, then because the winning bid did not contain a uniform unit price.

The lesson

For contracting authorities: a filter for the price examination is allowed, but test it against two questions. Does it let through items you yourself consider non-negligible? And does it set the same bar for all bidders? An absolute threshold in euros, or a percentage of the estimate or of the average bid, is easier to defend than a percentage of each bidder’s own total. Fix the method before the bids are opened, describe it unambiguously in the report and defend it before the Council as written — not in a new version at the hearing. Templates borrowed from other authorities are no guarantee. For bidders: request the award report and the explanation of the price examination, and work out what the filter means in practice. Concrete worked examples using the chosen tenderer’s figures, as S. NV provided, make an abstract complaint tangible.

Ask yourself

As an authority: which items escape your price examination because of the way you select, and would you call them negligible yourself? Does your selection threshold depend on the bidder’s own bid, so that the same deviation is queried for one bidder but not for another? Is the screening method described in the report so that no second reading is possible, and does the file support that reading? Have you tested a borrowed method against equal treatment yourself, or do you rely on others using it too? As a bidder: have you requested the price-examination method and run it against the chosen tenderer’s bid?

About this database

The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →