Suspension Dutch-speaking chamber

One euro cent ‘on top’ or ‘included’? Mechelen adds the surcharge for parking sensors to the charging price, P. drops to second place, and the Council of State suspends the award of the charging-point concession over an ambiguous price criterion

Ruling nr. 267937 · 6 October 2026 · XIVe kamer

For the concession of public charging points in Mechelen, P. BV offered a maximum charging-service price of 0.28 euros per kWh, after which the city added the 0.01 euros for the mandatory option ‘parking sensors’ — although its own answer in the Q&A note said that this extra cost could come ‘on top of the maximum Charging Service Price’ — so that Q. BV won by 95 to 94.62 points; the Council of State suspends the award because the price criterion, worth 40 points, was not transparent.

What happened?

The cities of Mechelen and Leuven jointly put out a services concession for supplying, installing, taking over, maintaining and operating publicly accessible normal charging infrastructure for electric vehicles, in two lots: lot 1 for Mechelen, lot 2 for Leuven. The procedure was a simplified negotiated procedure with European publication. The operating model assumed that the concessionaire would finance everything itself and pay a concession fee, and that the electric driver would contribute only through an energy tariff, possibly supplemented by a rotation tariff. There were two award criteria: price (40 points) and quality (60 points). The price criterion was called ‘Maximum Charging Service Price per kWh to the e-driver’: the bidder had to enter ‘which maximum Charging Service Price’ it would apply on the tender form and in the price inventory, whose only item was the ‘charging service price per kWh to the e-driver’, in a column headed ‘Price criterion’. The concession guidance document also provided for a mandatory option 2, ‘Parking sensors’. For Mechelen, the city could decide to have sensors integrated; this could ‘have a limited impact on the Charging Service Price’, with a maximum increase of 0.01 euros per kWh. In reply to question 71 in the Q&A note of 18 May 2026, Mechelen stated that purchase, installation, management and integration of the sensors were for the concessionaire’s account, that the 0.01 euros covered all costs, and that ‘where applicable, this extra cost may be charged on top of the maximum Charging Service Price’. Five bidders submitted an initial tender. The two best ranked, P. BV and Q. BV (both pseudonymised in the published judgment), were invited to submit a BAFO. P. entered 0.28 euros per kWh in the inventory and attached 0.01 euros to the sensor option. In the evaluation report Mechelen added that surcharge to the charging-service price, explaining that mandatory options form part of the tender and are assessed together with the base tender. Result: Q. scored 40/40 on price and 55/60 on quality, 95/100 in total; P. scored 38.62/40 on price and 56/60 on quality, 94.62 in total. The report itself put it this way: P. ‘scores slightly higher on quality in substance’, but because of the price impact of the option Q. obtained the highest total score. On 18 August 2026 the board of mayor and aldermen awarded lot 1 to Q. P. applied on 9 September 2026 for suspension under extreme urgency; Q. intervened. Mechelen and Q. first disputed P.’s interest: nothing suggested that it would have offered a different price. On the merits they argued that the guidance document left no doubt, that P. was pushing an ‘aberrant’ reading, that adding the surcharge reflected economic reality because Mechelen would certainly exercise the option, and that article 87, § 1, third paragraph, of the Royal Decree of 18 April 2017 requires exactly that approach for public contracts. Councillor of State Inge Vos, acting as presiding judge, saw it differently. The guidance document did contain some support for Mechelen’s reading, but the instruction to enter the ‘maximum’ charging-service price in the inventory, the column heading ‘Price criterion’ and above all the answer to question 71, which placed the extra cost ‘on top of’ the maximum charging-service price, rather supported P.’s reading. There was no question of an aberrant interpretation. The 40-point price criterion was therefore open to two readings and had also led to different interpretations among bidders. P. could not be blamed for not asking a further question: its reading matched the text and the city’s own answer, and there was no contradiction recognisable to a normally prudent bidder. Neither the questions put in the BAFO phase nor the reliance on article 87 of the Royal Decree of 18 April 2017, applicable to a concession at most by analogy, changed that. Mechelen thus appeared to have breached article 24, first paragraph, and article 55, § 1, of the Concessions Act of 17 June 2016, as well as the duty of care. P. did have an interest: the report itself showed that the disputed assessment gave Q. the highest score, and P. was denied the guarantee that everyone could read the criterion in the same way. The Council also noted that the pleading note P. filed the day before the hearing was accepted only as information and not as a procedural document. In line with the opinion of first auditor Frederic Eggermont, Q.’s intervention was granted and the award of lot 1 suspended.

Why does this matter?

In charging-point concessions the price per kWh is often the only price element, and margins are small: according to the evaluation report itself, one euro cent per kWh was decisive here, with a difference of 0.38 points out of 100. That makes the exact definition of what falls under ‘price’ decisive. The judgment shows how an answer in the Q&A note, meant to clarify, actually creates the ambiguity: an authority that writes that an extra cost may come ‘on top of’ the maximum price can hardly argue afterwards that this cost was included in the maximum price to be assessed. The Council places the burden of that lack of clarity on the authority, not on the bidder that asked no further question: a bidder need not spot a contradiction that a normally careful reader would not see. That the other bidder followed the city’s reading does not save the procedure. The judgment is also relevant for those awarding concessions who rely on public procurement rules: a rule such as article 87 of the Royal Decree of 18 April 2017 on mandatory options can at most play a role by analogy and does not replace a clear concession guidance document. Finally, the Council confirms that the interest requirement must not be applied formalistically: the applicant need not show that it would certainly have won under a different reading.

The lesson

For contracting authorities: if a mandatory option affects the price, state expressly how it counts in the price assessment and give it its own line in the price inventory. Check your answers in the Q&A note against the text of the guidance document: a single word such as ‘on top of’ can undermine a 40-point award criterion. An interpretation you only explain in the evaluation report comes too late. And do not assume that rules from the procurement award decree automatically apply to a concession. For bidders: when an option carries a surcharge, record expressly how you expect it to be assessed, and keep the Q&A answers you rely on. A reading that matches the text and the authority’s answers is defensible, even if a competitor read the documents differently.

Ask yourself

As an authority: does your guidance document state unambiguously whether the surcharge for a mandatory option counts in the price criterion, and does that surcharge have its own item in the inventory? Do your answers in the Q&A note contradict the text of the guidance document, even by a single word? Is your assessment method grounded in the procurement documents, or only in an explanation in the evaluation report? In a concession, are you relying on rules from the procurement award decree that do not apply directly? As a bidder: can you support your reading of the price criterion with both the text of the guidance document and the authority’s answers?

About this database

The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →