A ‘public’ timber sale behind closed doors: the Council of State annuls Habay’s award of eight lots of spruce, Covid or not
In May 2021 the Walloon forestry district of Habay opened the tenders for a grouped sale of spruce behind closed doors, citing the coronavirus measures; the Council of State holds that an ‘adjudication publique’ under the Forestry Code by definition requires a public session, that the Covid protocol in force actually allowed such a session, and annuls the municipality of Habay’s decision to award lots 10 to 17 — on an action brought by the Belgian Timber Confederation and a timber harvester that had not itself submitted a tender.
What happened?
On 10 May 2021 the Habay district of the Département de la Nature et des Forêts (DNF) announced a grouped public sale of standing spruce, by sealed tender and lot by lot, on behalf of the municipalities of Habay and Arlon, the state forest of Mellier and the undivided state forest of Anlier: 19 lots in all. Because of ‘the lockdown measures of the ministerial order of 18 March 2020’, tenders had to be submitted by email or post by 24 May 2021 at noon; opening would take place on 25 May ‘à huis clos’. The notice was posted to around 80 operators from the DNF database — Entreprise A. Hubert was not among them — and appeared on wallowood.be, on a date that could not be established. The Confédération belge du Bois protested from 14 May onward, served a formal notice by bailiff on 25 May not to conclude the sale, and repeatedly asked the municipalities of Habay and Arlon not to confirm the sale of their own timber. The tenders were nevertheless opened behind closed doors on 25 May at 12:10. On 7 June 2021 the Habay college decided to award lots 10 to 17. It relied on an email from the district head, who criticised the federation’s ‘methods’ and pointed out that the massive bark-beetle flight made it all the more urgent to have the timber harvested quickly. Only after two reminders did the municipality send the decision to the applicants’ lawyers on 22 July; the action followed on 28 September 2021. The Council first rejects the objections. The action is timely: the act did not have to be published or notified, the federation received it only on 31 July 2021 after repeated requests, and no one can be blamed for being late against a decision that had not yet been taken. The federation has standing because the sale affects the specific collective interests in its articles: promoting the timber sector, adequate competition and preventing such practices from becoming a line of conduct. Entreprise A. Hubert also has standing: a party that did not take part in a disposal procedure cannot in principle challenge the award, but it can if it claims it was unable to take part for reasons it is criticising. On the merits, the Council notes that the Forestry Code does not define ‘adjudication publique’ and that the meaning of the term in public-procurement legislation is irrelevant here, as that legislation does not apply. Relying on legal writing, a Court of Cassation judgment of 9 March 1839 and the preparatory works of the 1854 Forestry Code, it holds that a public adjudication presupposes the simultaneous, announced presence of interested parties in a room open to all — it rules out a closed session. The municipality’s reading that ‘publique’ refers only to publicity fails: publicity is already dealt with separately in article 73, second paragraph. The public session is moreover a safeguard for the regularity of the operations, including the settlement of disputes by the chair (art. 76) and the provision of security ‘séance tenante’ (art. 77). The municipality did not show that the Covid rules allowed a sale behind closed doors: the ministerial order of 18 March 2020 it cited was no longer in force; on 10 May 2021 the order of 28 October 2020 applied, and the ministerial protocol of 5 November 2020 set out precisely how public timber sales could go ahead, with a maximum of 40 people, 10 m² per participant, one representative per buyer and face masks. Nor did the urgent removal of bark-beetle timber justify a closed session once a public adjudication had been chosen. The decision of 7 June 2021 breaches article 73 of the Forestry Code and is annulled, without examining the other pleas. Habay bears the costs: 400 euros roll fee, 20 euros contribution and 770 euros procedural indemnity. A separate action is pending against the DNF’s award of the lots from the state forests.
Why does this matter?
This is not a classic public contract — the authority is selling here, not buying — and the Council expressly states that procurement legislation does not apply. Yet the judgment is instructive for anyone contracting with public authorities. First, it shows how far the Council goes in recognising standing. A trade federation may challenge a specific award to prevent an irregular practice from becoming a line of conduct, even when the authority calls the circumstances ‘exceptional’. And an operator that submitted no tender has standing if it claims it could not take part because of the criticised method; its ‘moral benefit’ suffices. That runs counter to the oft-heard claim that those who do not take part may not complain. Second, it is a lesson in literal reading: when a decree imposes a ‘public’ procedure, an authority cannot reduce that to ‘sufficient publicity’, and a crisis does not justify a departure when the crisis protocol in force made the public form possible. Third, the judgment confirms that the time limit against an act that need not be published runs only from knowledge of it, so an authority that drags its feet on documents cannot plead lateness. For the forestry sector in Wallonia — where timber from public forests must in principle be sold by public adjudication — the message is clear: opening tenders behind closed doors is out.
The lesson
For authorities selling goods or awarding contracts: read the formal requirements of your rules literally and check which safeguards attach to them. If you need to depart for urgent reasons, use the exception the law itself provides (here, private sale of trees to be felled urgently for health reasons) rather than unilaterally adapting the chosen procedure. In a crisis, refer to the rules in force at that moment, not to a superseded order. And do not ignore a formal notice from a trade federation: it has standing to go to the Council of State. For businesses: if you did not bid because the procedure itself was irregular, you are not automatically barred from an action, but make clear that you could and wanted to take part. Request the decision and the file in good time and in writing; that correspondence later proves your diligence.
Ask yourself
As a selling or contracting authority: do you know which safeguards (public session, settlement of disputes, provision of security) attach to the procedure you choose, and do you respect them under time pressure too? Do you base a departure on the rules actually in force at that moment, or on an order that has since been replaced? Have you considered using the statutory exception procedure instead of adapting the ordinary procedure on your own initiative? As a business that did not bid: can you show that the criticised method prevented or deterred you from taking part? As a trade federation: does the contested conduct fall within your association’s statutory purpose, and did you put the authority on formal notice in writing beforehand?
About this database
The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →